{"key":"cancel-a","idea":"d-s23-retreat-cancel: cancel the side the rival just retreated from, spreads 2 and 3, vs comparator N","candidate_sha256":"3c07bdcd221ac25729c3ebc92b21ac9e2014510ecb85816c4391ed81e933291f","comparator_sha256":"bf0d179f3e47d28819f6fa7e0d25548c2ced43374c216d36460b00a26a26ffae","seeds":{"start":430500,"end":430999},"n":500,"complete":true,"missing_seeds":[],"failures":[],"check_values":[17.116002,20.017111,2.390311,241.484752],"python_version":"3.12.3","seconds_per_simulation":6.681,"overall":{"n":500,"sum_d":214.764146,"sum_d2":2876.650118,"mean_diff":0.4295282910062009,"se":0.10564057567105217,"comparator_mean":109.4414535838618,"candidate_mean":109.870981874868,"retail_diff":-0.16849544021300744,"arb_diff":0.5980237312284018},"by_spread":{"1":{"n":122,"sum_d":0.0,"sum_d2":0.0,"mean_diff":0.0,"se":0.0,"comparator_mean":45.75923746144918,"candidate_mean":45.75923746144918,"retail_diff":0.0,"arb_diff":0.0},"2":{"n":118,"sum_d":66.825773,"sum_d2":2063.878328,"mean_diff":0.5663201131076296,"se":0.3830799144181805,"comparator_mean":95.62232832857796,"candidate_mean":96.1886484416856,"retail_diff":-0.46858918755677337,"arb_diff":1.0349093007118633},"3":{"n":131,"sum_d":147.938372,"sum_d2":812.771789,"mean_diff":1.1293005508122147,"se":0.1947196223217454,"comparator_mean":114.67834917048931,"candidate_mean":115.80764972130152,"retail_diff":-0.2210243967541885,"arb_diff":1.3503249475587786},"4":{"n":129,"sum_d":0.0,"sum_d2":0.0,"mean_diff":0.0,"se":0.0,"comparator_mean":176.99070804285114,"candidate_mean":176.99070804285114,"retail_diff":0.0,"arb_diff":0.0}},"per_seed":[[430500,4,0.0],[430501,1,0.0],[430502,1,0.0],[430503,3,0.559329],[430504,4,0.0],[430505,2,-0.279071],[430506,4,0.0],[430507,3,0.371061],[430508,4,0.0],[430509,4,0.0],[430510,2,0.099673],[430511,4,0.0],[430512,4,0.0],[430513,4,0.0],[430514,4,0.0],[430515,3,-0.043758],[430516,1,0.0],[430517,4,0.0],[430518,1,0.0],[430519,1,0.0],[430520,1,0.0],[430521,4,0.0],[430522,1,0.0],[430523,4,0.0],[430524,4,0.0],[430525,3,0.606645],[430526,4,0.0],[430527,4,0.0],[430528,4,0.0],[430529,3,0.219392],[430530,3,-0.273525],[430531,3,0.183767],[430532,2,3.817046],[430533,4,0.0],[430534,3,0.29231],[430535,1,0.0],[430536,3,0.580018],[430537,1,0.0],[430538,1,0.0],[430539,4,0.0],[430540,4,0.0],[430541,4,0.0],[430542,2,0.096079],[430543,2,1.365995],[430544,2,0.270694],[430545,1,0.0],[430546,1,0.0],[430547,1,0.0],[430548,1,0.0],[430549,3,-0.201853],[430550,3,7.530847],[430551,1,0.0],[430552,3,0.071227],[430553,4,0.0],[430554,3,-0.367272],[430555,2,0.457314],[430556,2,-5.268496],[430557,2,0.089349],[430558,2,3.002856],[430559,4,0.0],[430560,3,0.372032],[430561,3,0.068777],[430562,1,0.0],[430563,3,0.252971],[430564,3,4.670198],[430565,1,0.0],[430566,1,0.0],[430567,1,0.0],[430568,2,-0.133866],[430569,4,0.0],[430570,4,0.0],[430571,3,1.557281],[430572,3,0.968525],[430573,4,0.0],[430574,4,0.0],[430575,3,4.734266],[430576,2,1.576599],[430577,3,0.340518],[430578,3,0.124556],[430579,4,0.0],[430580,3,5.543251],[430581,4,0.0],[430582,2,-8.722369],[430583,1,0.0],[430584,4,0.0],[430585,2,-4.802193],[430586,4,0.0],[430587,2,0.493079],[430588,4,0.0],[430589,3,1.952386],[430590,1,0.0],[430591,2,-0.365505],[430592,4,0.0],[430593,4,0.0],[430594,1,0.0],[430595,3,0.111388],[430596,3,0.561423],[430597,1,0.0],[430598,1,0.0],[430599,3,1.801914],[430600,2,14.483121],[430601,4,0.0],[430602,4,0.0],[430603,2,0.121408],[430604,2,-0.265291],[430605,4,0.0],[430606,4,0.0],[430607,3,-0.122668],[430608,2,0.192357],[430609,3,0.385551],[430610,2,0.046194],[430611,2,0.345572],[430612,3,3.642781],[430613,3,1.714865],[430614,1,0.0],[430615,4,0.0],[430616,1,0.0],[430617,2,-0.136525],[430618,3,13.669665],[430619,3,1.412898],[430620,4,0.0],[430621,2,0.211065],[430622,4,0.0],[430623,1,0.0],[430624,1,0.0],[430625,4,0.0],[430626,4,0.0],[430627,1,0.0],[430628,4,0.0],[430629,2,0.458992],[430630,1,0.0],[430631,2,-0.368936],[430632,1,0.0],[430633,2,-0.588114],[430634,1,0.0],[430635,2,-0.450545],[430636,1,0.0],[430637,3,0.030078],[430638,1,0.0],[430639,2,-0.707366],[430640,2,-4.813985],[430641,2,3.418754],[430642,3,0.532982],[430643,2,-0.229632],[430644,3,-0.345822],[430645,3,-0.205551],[430646,4,0.0],[430647,1,0.0],[430648,3,-0.222666],[430649,4,0.0],[430650,1,0.0],[430651,2,-0.461658],[430652,1,0.0],[430653,4,0.0],[430654,2,0.268868],[430655,4,0.0],[430656,3,4.736517],[430657,3,-0.303746],[430658,2,-0.585942],[430659,3,0.772571],[430660,2,-0.166495],[430661,4,0.0],[430662,2,0.12065],[430663,3,0.143181],[430664,4,0.0],[430665,1,0.0],[430666,2,1.639825],[430667,4,0.0],[430668,2,0.382671],[430669,3,1.287764],[430670,4,0.0],[430671,4,0.0],[430672,1,0.0],[430673,1,0.0],[430674,3,-0.650651],[430675,2,0.653681],[430676,4,0.0],[430677,2,0.072398],[430678,3,1.036126],[430679,3,-0.859141],[430680,1,0.0],[430681,2,2.73642],[430682,3,1.455694],[430683,1,0.0],[430684,3,3.028432],[430685,1,0.0],[430686,1,0.0],[430687,4,0.0],[430688,2,-1.437382],[430689,2,0.641282],[430690,3,0.781344],[430691,2,-3.45756],[430692,2,6.041751],[430693,1,0.0],[430694,3,-3.699058],[430695,3,1.340844],[430696,2,-1.803873],[430697,4,0.0],[430698,2,3.277884],[430699,4,0.0],[430700,2,0.34018],[430701,1,0.0],[430702,4,0.0],[430703,1,0.0],[430704,4,0.0],[430705,1,0.0],[430706,3,0.021563],[430707,3,2.820069],[430708,1,0.0],[430709,1,0.0],[430710,4,0.0],[430711,4,0.0],[430712,2,0.576344],[430713,1,0.0],[430714,1,0.0],[430715,2,0.379389],[430716,3,0.26731],[430717,1,0.0],[430718,4,0.0],[430719,3,0.350633],[430720,3,0.077549],[430721,3,5.670238],[430722,3,-0.367073],[430723,2,-1.794803],[430724,2,1.731994],[430725,1,0.0],[430726,3,0.416411],[430727,3,0.805087],[430728,4,0.0],[430729,3,0.221268],[430730,1,0.0],[430731,4,0.0],[430732,1,0.0],[430733,1,0.0],[430734,4,0.0],[430735,3,6.504129],[430736,1,0.0],[430737,3,0.455829],[430738,4,0.0],[430739,4,0.0],[430740,2,-0.142144],[430741,3,1.552385],[430742,4,0.0],[430743,3,4.834022],[430744,4,0.0],[430745,1,0.0],[430746,1,0.0],[430747,2,0.287281],[430748,3,6.673428],[430749,2,-1.38219],[430750,2,0.274251],[430751,2,1.232939],[430752,2,5.564189],[430753,2,12.309554],[430754,4,0.0],[430755,3,0.492513],[430756,3,3.197384],[430757,4,0.0],[430758,3,0.294995],[430759,1,0.0],[430760,3,0.280211],[430761,2,0.06795],[430762,4,0.0],[430763,3,-0.02556],[430764,2,-0.578602],[430765,2,-0.202578],[430766,2,-0.098793],[430767,3,0.432685],[430768,1,0.0],[430769,2,0.565628],[430770,1,0.0],[430771,3,0.113183],[430772,1,0.0],[430773,3,1.494404],[430774,4,0.0],[430775,1,0.0],[430776,4,0.0],[430777,3,0.279728],[430778,4,0.0],[430779,2,7.346641],[430780,2,-19.160168],[430781,4,0.0],[430782,1,0.0],[430783,3,0.327736],[430784,4,0.0],[430785,3,1.108632],[430786,2,2.009439],[430787,1,0.0],[430788,3,0.186328],[430789,3,1.01089],[430790,1,0.0],[430791,3,0.907558],[430792,2,-0.264697],[430793,1,0.0],[430794,3,2.936709],[430795,1,0.0],[430796,1,0.0],[430797,4,0.0],[430798,2,1.521733],[430799,1,0.0],[430800,2,2.480113],[430801,2,0.461327],[430802,1,0.0],[430803,3,-6.727517],[430804,4,0.0],[430805,1,0.0],[430806,1,0.0],[430807,1,0.0],[430808,3,0.643515],[430809,3,0.047721],[430810,3,-0.777855],[430811,2,0.837529],[430812,3,0.355188],[430813,4,0.0],[430814,4,0.0],[430815,1,0.0],[430816,2,0.746676],[430817,1,0.0],[430818,3,0.11804],[430819,3,0.220855],[430820,1,0.0],[430821,3,0.091081],[430822,1,0.0],[430823,2,0.315644],[430824,2,-1.230954],[430825,3,5.490238],[430826,4,0.0],[430827,2,0.650904],[430828,4,0.0],[430829,2,0.276011],[430830,4,0.0],[430831,3,0.394212],[430832,3,0.151351],[430833,3,1.147781],[430834,1,0.0],[430835,1,0.0],[430836,1,0.0],[430837,3,0.158003],[430838,4,0.0],[430839,2,-0.532247],[430840,3,5.949951],[430841,4,0.0],[430842,3,0.801376],[430843,4,0.0],[430844,3,2.120626],[430845,2,0.00451],[430846,4,0.0],[430847,4,0.0],[430848,1,0.0],[430849,1,0.0],[430850,4,0.0],[430851,2,12.500696],[430852,3,-0.63006],[430853,3,0.530651],[430854,4,0.0],[430855,1,0.0],[430856,3,-0.966269],[430857,2,0.319646],[430858,2,3.503706],[430859,2,-0.55938],[430860,1,0.0],[430861,1,0.0],[430862,1,0.0],[430863,3,1.058461],[430864,3,0.488814],[430865,4,0.0],[430866,3,0.25163],[430867,1,0.0],[430868,2,0.451526],[430869,4,0.0],[430870,2,-0.286561],[430871,1,0.0],[430872,4,0.0],[430873,3,0.781423],[430874,4,0.0],[430875,2,0.170656],[430876,2,-0.041795],[430877,4,0.0],[430878,2,0.141717],[430879,3,3.059485],[430880,2,0.144153],[430881,1,0.0],[430882,3,-0.092299],[430883,4,0.0],[430884,3,-1.680138],[430885,1,0.0],[430886,1,0.0],[430887,3,0.099344],[430888,3,0.595696],[430889,3,5.962091],[430890,1,0.0],[430891,2,-0.02019],[430892,3,3.701726],[430893,4,0.0],[430894,4,0.0],[430895,2,-0.258669],[430896,1,0.0],[430897,1,0.0],[430898,4,0.0],[430899,4,0.0],[430900,2,2.24659],[430901,3,0.348779],[430902,2,-2.363423],[430903,4,0.0],[430904,2,0.369897],[430905,4,0.0],[430906,1,0.0],[430907,2,0.223318],[430908,3,0.52103],[430909,3,0.5443],[430910,3,0.634723],[430911,4,0.0],[430912,2,0.53308],[430913,4,0.0],[430914,2,0.429221],[430915,3,0.069328],[430916,1,0.0],[430917,2,0.2591],[430918,1,0.0],[430919,4,0.0],[430920,2,21.513935],[430921,1,0.0],[430922,4,0.0],[430923,4,0.0],[430924,1,0.0],[430925,3,0.976527],[430926,1,0.0],[430927,2,0.03537],[430928,1,0.0],[430929,2,1.27316],[430930,4,0.0],[430931,4,0.0],[430932,1,0.0],[430933,1,0.0],[430934,2,0.124089],[430935,4,0.0],[430936,4,0.0],[430937,4,0.0],[430938,1,0.0],[430939,3,3.723832],[430940,3,1.391269],[430941,2,1.044286],[430942,4,0.0],[430943,2,0.793496],[430944,4,0.0],[430945,3,1.11453],[430946,1,0.0],[430947,4,0.0],[430948,1,0.0],[430949,2,0.015281],[430950,1,0.0],[430951,2,5.341759],[430952,3,0.341295],[430953,2,0.398989],[430954,1,0.0],[430955,3,2.594222],[430956,2,3.189365],[430957,4,0.0],[430958,2,-16.04552],[430959,2,0.140741],[430960,1,0.0],[430961,3,0.905724],[430962,2,0.116709],[430963,1,0.0],[430964,4,0.0],[430965,4,0.0],[430966,1,0.0],[430967,4,0.0],[430968,4,0.0],[430969,2,1.002564],[430970,3,0.163437],[430971,2,0.098905],[430972,1,0.0],[430973,2,3.059098],[430974,3,0.128603],[430975,3,0.200453],[430976,4,0.0],[430977,2,0.038229],[430978,1,0.0],[430979,1,0.0],[430980,1,0.0],[430981,4,0.0],[430982,3,4.123416],[430983,4,0.0],[430984,1,0.0],[430985,4,0.0],[430986,1,0.0],[430987,1,0.0],[430988,3,0.426438],[430989,4,0.0],[430990,3,0.700335],[430991,3,-0.402494],[430992,1,0.0],[430993,4,0.0],[430994,3,0.597598],[430995,4,0.0],[430996,4,0.0],[430997,2,0.81534],[430998,4,0.0],[430999,2,0.176865]],"notes":"Check values for N on 310000-310003 matched to 6 decimals. Both hashes verified. Observed first rival quotes: ask-bid=2s-1 on every seed. Unmodified simulator b244530, serial, 4 processes in parallel; each seed run once per strategy. Spread-3 gain is small relative to se; read by_spread."}