{ "key": "s4-f-4", "idea": "Finalist measurement of B_RC4 versus B_RC: add the one-tick retreat cancel on spread 4 only.", "candidate_sha256": "27cef4140f19ecf15aeaa82c8a4bc70f9f066083a5bed10bcb963d8ecbb9b8aa", "comparator_sha256": "02696ea6fd0922f64167a1153748f6a38bf2fd5d87c7a4ac6cb974bb9482f57c", "seeds": { "start": 901500, "end": 901999 }, "n": 500, "complete": true, "missing_seeds": [], "failures": [], "check_values": [ { "seed": 310000, "comparator_total_edge": 17.5126554022, "expected": 17.512655, "matches_6dp": true }, { "seed": 310001, "comparator_total_edge": 24.2585786274, "expected": 24.258579, "matches_6dp": true }, { "seed": 310002, "comparator_total_edge": 2.3903113616, "expected": 2.390311, "matches_6dp": true }, { "seed": 310003, "comparator_total_edge": 249.5411334743, "expected": 249.541133, "matches_6dp": true } ], "python_version": "3.10.12", "seconds_per_simulation": { "overall": { "candidate": 1.2564691333603113, "comparator": 1.2508440234782174 }, "by_spread": { "1": { "candidate": 1.0886836601886898, "comparator": 1.0938339532876853 }, "2": { "candidate": 1.2504246341816794, "comparator": 1.2580589973972214 }, "3": { "candidate": 1.3180554689836084, "comparator": 1.2812715114441013 }, "4": { "candidate": 1.3451422032508196, "comparator": 1.351004349262112 } } }, "overall": { "n": 500, "sum_d": 49.122824986999916, "sum_d2": 573.8611393705061, "mean_diff": 0.09824564997399984, "se": 0.04775669110286626, "comparator_mean": 102.4990271214684, "retail_diff": -0.03814783844139975, "arb_diff": 0.1363934884213998 }, "by_spread": { "1": { "n": 120, "sum_d": 0.0, "sum_d2": 0.0, "mean_diff": 0.0, "se": 0.0, "comparator_mean": 51.07364955841334, "retail_diff": 0.0, "arb_diff": 0.0 }, "2": { "n": 104, "sum_d": 0.0, "sum_d2": 0.0, "mean_diff": 0.0, "se": 0.0, "comparator_mean": 63.093300743718274, "retail_diff": 0.0, "arb_diff": 0.0 }, "3": { "n": 137, "sum_d": 0.0, "sum_d2": 0.0, "mean_diff": 0.0, "se": 0.0, "comparator_mean": 131.55542751700364, "retail_diff": 0.0, "arb_diff": 0.0 }, "4": { "n": 139, "sum_d": 49.122824986999916, "sum_d2": 573.8611393705061, "mean_diff": 0.3534016186115102, "se": 0.17032800201899398, "comparator_mean": 147.74013501113956, "retail_diff": -0.13722244043668977, "arb_diff": 0.4906240590697835 } }, "per_seed": [ [901500, 1, 0.000000], [901501, 1, 0.000000], [901502, 3, 0.000000], [901503, 4, -1.608339], [901504, 2, 0.000000], [901505, 1, 0.000000], [901506, 3, 0.000000], [901507, 4, -0.077005], [901508, 1, 0.000000], [901509, 4, 2.174774], [901510, 4, 0.681586], [901511, 4, 0.786796], [901512, 3, 0.000000], [901513, 3, 0.000000], [901514, 4, -1.322856], [901515, 2, 0.000000], [901516, 4, 0.402235], [901517, 4, 1.938621], [901518, 1, 0.000000], [901519, 1, 0.000000], [901520, 4, -1.096364], [901521, 1, 0.000000], [901522, 3, 0.000000], [901523, 4, 0.061254], [901524, 2, 0.000000], [901525, 1, 0.000000], [901526, 3, 0.000000], [901527, 4, 0.027522], [901528, 4, 0.198787], [901529, 4, 1.773060], [901530, 1, 0.000000], [901531, 2, 0.000000], [901532, 2, 0.000000], [901533, 1, 0.000000], [901534, 3, 0.000000], [901535, 3, 0.000000], [901536, 4, -0.388635], [901537, 3, 0.000000], [901538, 4, 1.031363], [901539, 3, 0.000000], [901540, 3, 0.000000], [901541, 4, 0.379848], [901542, 1, 0.000000], [901543, 1, 0.000000], [901544, 1, 0.000000], [901545, 2, 0.000000], [901546, 2, 0.000000], [901547, 1, 0.000000], [901548, 2, 0.000000], [901549, 4, 0.146637], [901550, 4, 0.670030], [901551, 3, 0.000000], [901552, 2, 0.000000], [901553, 4, 0.469702], [901554, 4, 4.047916], [901555, 2, 0.000000], [901556, 4, 0.721446], [901557, 3, 0.000000], [901558, 3, 0.000000], [901559, 3, 0.000000], [901560, 4, 1.018304], [901561, 4, 0.091156], [901562, 3, 0.000000], [901563, 4, -0.239444], [901564, 2, 0.000000], [901565, 4, -0.171620], [901566, 4, -0.044911], [901567, 3, 0.000000], [901568, 3, 0.000000], [901569, 4, -2.936675], [901570, 4, -0.110464], [901571, 3, 0.000000], [901572, 3, 0.000000], [901573, 1, 0.000000], [901574, 2, 0.000000], [901575, 4, 2.129652], [901576, 4, 1.610824], [901577, 3, 0.000000], [901578, 4, 0.184502], [901579, 2, 0.000000], [901580, 2, 0.000000], [901581, 2, 0.000000], [901582, 4, 0.174214], [901583, 2, 0.000000], [901584, 3, 0.000000], [901585, 4, -0.501167], [901586, 2, 0.000000], [901587, 3, 0.000000], [901588, 3, 0.000000], [901589, 3, 0.000000], [901590, 1, 0.000000], [901591, 3, 0.000000], [901592, 4, 0.360965], [901593, 4, 1.419500], [901594, 3, 0.000000], [901595, 1, 0.000000], [901596, 4, 0.039878], [901597, 4, -0.331653], [901598, 1, 0.000000], [901599, 1, 0.000000], [901600, 1, 0.000000], [901601, 1, 0.000000], [901602, 2, 0.000000], [901603, 3, 0.000000], [901604, 4, -0.713970], [901605, 2, 0.000000], [901606, 4, 0.318696], [901607, 1, 0.000000], [901608, 3, 0.000000], [901609, 4, 0.340544], [901610, 2, 0.000000], [901611, 2, 0.000000], [901612, 2, 0.000000], [901613, 1, 0.000000], [901614, 1, 0.000000], [901615, 2, 0.000000], [901616, 3, 0.000000], [901617, 3, 0.000000], [901618, 4, 0.808442], [901619, 2, 0.000000], [901620, 4, -0.581623], [901621, 3, 0.000000], [901622, 3, 0.000000], [901623, 4, -0.618188], [901624, 1, 0.000000], [901625, 1, 0.000000], [901626, 1, 0.000000], [901627, 3, 0.000000], [901628, 3, 0.000000], [901629, 4, 0.337622], [901630, 4, 0.001834], [901631, 2, 0.000000], [901632, 1, 0.000000], [901633, 3, 0.000000], [901634, 1, 0.000000], [901635, 3, 0.000000], [901636, 2, 0.000000], [901637, 4, 0.255541], [901638, 3, 0.000000], [901639, 2, 0.000000], [901640, 1, 0.000000], [901641, 4, 0.166166], [901642, 4, 0.025654], [901643, 2, 0.000000], [901644, 1, 0.000000], [901645, 4, 0.976174], [901646, 2, 0.000000], [901647, 1, 0.000000], [901648, 4, 0.161286], [901649, 4, 0.183895], [901650, 4, 2.813612], [901651, 3, 0.000000], [901652, 2, 0.000000], [901653, 1, 0.000000], [901654, 2, 0.000000], [901655, 1, 0.000000], [901656, 3, 0.000000], [901657, 2, 0.000000], [901658, 2, 0.000000], [901659, 3, 0.000000], [901660, 4, 0.499623], [901661, 1, 0.000000], [901662, 1, 0.000000], [901663, 3, 0.000000], [901664, 4, -1.182483], [901665, 2, 0.000000], [901666, 2, 0.000000], [901667, 1, 0.000000], [901668, 3, 0.000000], [901669, 3, 0.000000], [901670, 4, 0.396346], [901671, 2, 0.000000], [901672, 3, 0.000000], [901673, 4, 2.741468], [901674, 4, 0.246494], [901675, 3, 0.000000], [901676, 2, 0.000000], [901677, 1, 0.000000], [901678, 2, 0.000000], [901679, 1, 0.000000], [901680, 3, 0.000000], [901681, 1, 0.000000], [901682, 1, 0.000000], [901683, 2, 0.000000], [901684, 4, -0.445496], [901685, 3, 0.000000], [901686, 1, 0.000000], [901687, 3, 0.000000], [901688, 4, -0.043875], [901689, 1, 0.000000], [901690, 3, 0.000000], [901691, 2, 0.000000], [901692, 1, 0.000000], [901693, 2, 0.000000], [901694, 1, 0.000000], [901695, 4, 0.161147], [901696, 1, 0.000000], [901697, 2, 0.000000], [901698, 2, 0.000000], [901699, 4, 0.233074], [901700, 3, 0.000000], [901701, 2, 0.000000], [901702, 2, 0.000000], [901703, 1, 0.000000], [901704, 3, 0.000000], [901705, 4, -0.094667], [901706, 1, 0.000000], [901707, 3, 0.000000], [901708, 4, 0.030404], [901709, 2, 0.000000], [901710, 4, 0.030542], [901711, 1, 0.000000], [901712, 2, 0.000000], [901713, 4, -16.437111], [901714, 3, 0.000000], [901715, 4, 0.515066], [901716, 3, 0.000000], [901717, 4, -0.283039], [901718, 2, 0.000000], [901719, 4, -0.096261], [901720, 1, 0.000000], [901721, 1, 0.000000], [901722, 3, 0.000000], [901723, 2, 0.000000], [901724, 2, 0.000000], [901725, 3, 0.000000], [901726, 2, 0.000000], [901727, 4, 1.736204], [901728, 3, 0.000000], [901729, 2, 0.000000], [901730, 1, 0.000000], [901731, 1, 0.000000], [901732, 2, 0.000000], [901733, 4, 0.125375], [901734, 4, 2.117593], [901735, 3, 0.000000], [901736, 4, -0.676573], [901737, 3, 0.000000], [901738, 3, 0.000000], [901739, 4, -0.643991], [901740, 2, 0.000000], [901741, 4, 0.054854], [901742, 1, 0.000000], [901743, 1, 0.000000], [901744, 1, 0.000000], [901745, 3, 0.000000], [901746, 3, 0.000000], [901747, 4, 0.161297], [901748, 1, 0.000000], [901749, 3, 0.000000], [901750, 3, 0.000000], [901751, 1, 0.000000], [901752, 3, 0.000000], [901753, 1, 0.000000], [901754, 3, 0.000000], [901755, 3, 0.000000], [901756, 2, 0.000000], [901757, 2, 0.000000], [901758, 2, 0.000000], [901759, 2, 0.000000], [901760, 4, 0.917325], [901761, 3, 0.000000], [901762, 4, 0.062246], [901763, 1, 0.000000], [901764, 4, 0.058170], [901765, 3, 0.000000], [901766, 4, 0.085854], [901767, 3, 0.000000], [901768, 3, 0.000000], [901769, 2, 0.000000], [901770, 1, 0.000000], [901771, 4, 0.168167], [901772, 3, 0.000000], [901773, 3, 0.000000], [901774, 4, 6.593169], [901775, 2, 0.000000], [901776, 3, 0.000000], [901777, 1, 0.000000], [901778, 4, -0.869452], [901779, 1, 0.000000], [901780, 1, 0.000000], [901781, 2, 0.000000], [901782, 4, 0.035326], [901783, 4, 0.177398], [901784, 3, 0.000000], [901785, 1, 0.000000], [901786, 4, 0.013758], [901787, 1, 0.000000], [901788, 1, 0.000000], [901789, 4, 0.580104], [901790, 3, 0.000000], [901791, 3, 0.000000], [901792, 4, 0.685586], [901793, 1, 0.000000], [901794, 3, 0.000000], [901795, 3, 0.000000], [901796, 4, 1.303512], [901797, 2, 0.000000], [901798, 1, 0.000000], [901799, 3, 0.000000], [901800, 1, 0.000000], [901801, 4, 3.098902], [901802, 2, 0.000000], [901803, 1, 0.000000], [901804, 2, 0.000000], [901805, 2, 0.000000], [901806, 3, 0.000000], [901807, 1, 0.000000], [901808, 4, 0.153981], [901809, 4, 0.358922], [901810, 2, 0.000000], [901811, 4, -0.567271], [901812, 3, 0.000000], [901813, 1, 0.000000], [901814, 3, 0.000000], [901815, 3, 0.000000], [901816, 2, 0.000000], [901817, 1, 0.000000], [901818, 3, 0.000000], [901819, 3, 0.000000], [901820, 1, 0.000000], [901821, 2, 0.000000], [901822, 1, 0.000000], [901823, 3, 0.000000], [901824, 2, 0.000000], [901825, 1, 0.000000], [901826, 3, 0.000000], [901827, 1, 0.000000], [901828, 3, 0.000000], [901829, 3, 0.000000], [901830, 3, 0.000000], [901831, 4, 0.163377], [901832, 3, 0.000000], [901833, 2, 0.000000], [901834, 4, 0.615239], [901835, 3, 0.000000], [901836, 3, 0.000000], [901837, 1, 0.000000], [901838, 4, 0.035117], [901839, 4, 1.094802], [901840, 4, 1.184982], [901841, 4, 2.714837], [901842, 4, -0.459928], [901843, 1, 0.000000], [901844, 3, 0.000000], [901845, 3, 0.000000], [901846, 4, 0.097866], [901847, 1, 0.000000], [901848, 1, 0.000000], [901849, 2, 0.000000], [901850, 2, 0.000000], [901851, 4, 1.505828], [901852, 1, 0.000000], [901853, 2, 0.000000], [901854, 3, 0.000000], [901855, 3, 0.000000], [901856, 1, 0.000000], [901857, 2, 0.000000], [901858, 3, 0.000000], [901859, 1, 0.000000], [901860, 4, 1.388594], [901861, 4, 0.075960], [901862, 2, 0.000000], [901863, 2, 0.000000], [901864, 4, 0.016836], [901865, 2, 0.000000], [901866, 2, 0.000000], [901867, 1, 0.000000], [901868, 2, 0.000000], [901869, 2, 0.000000], [901870, 3, 0.000000], [901871, 1, 0.000000], [901872, 4, 0.925854], [901873, 3, 0.000000], [901874, 4, 0.688083], [901875, 4, -4.188215], [901876, 4, 5.376251], [901877, 3, 0.000000], [901878, 3, 0.000000], [901879, 4, 0.149975], [901880, 1, 0.000000], [901881, 3, 0.000000], [901882, 2, 0.000000], [901883, 4, 0.175624], [901884, 3, 0.000000], [901885, 3, 0.000000], [901886, 1, 0.000000], [901887, 1, 0.000000], [901888, 3, 0.000000], [901889, 3, 0.000000], [901890, 1, 0.000000], [901891, 2, 0.000000], [901892, 3, 0.000000], [901893, 3, 0.000000], [901894, 1, 0.000000], [901895, 1, 0.000000], [901896, 1, 0.000000], [901897, 2, 0.000000], [901898, 3, 0.000000], [901899, 1, 0.000000], [901900, 3, 0.000000], [901901, 4, 0.386666], [901902, 1, 0.000000], [901903, 4, 2.399432], [901904, 4, 0.058440], [901905, 2, 0.000000], [901906, 2, 0.000000], [901907, 1, 0.000000], [901908, 4, 1.374011], [901909, 1, 0.000000], [901910, 4, -3.523544], [901911, 1, 0.000000], [901912, 1, 0.000000], [901913, 2, 0.000000], [901914, 4, 1.036106], [901915, 3, 0.000000], [901916, 3, 0.000000], [901917, 2, 0.000000], [901918, 2, 0.000000], [901919, 3, 0.000000], [901920, 3, 0.000000], [901921, 2, 0.000000], [901922, 1, 0.000000], [901923, 1, 0.000000], [901924, 3, 0.000000], [901925, 1, 0.000000], [901926, 3, 0.000000], [901927, 3, 0.000000], [901928, 4, -2.812149], [901929, 4, 0.185479], [901930, 4, 1.964106], [901931, 2, 0.000000], [901932, 4, 0.208690], [901933, 3, 0.000000], [901934, 2, 0.000000], [901935, 4, -0.251666], [901936, 4, 0.062839], [901937, 3, 0.000000], [901938, 3, 0.000000], [901939, 2, 0.000000], [901940, 3, 0.000000], [901941, 2, 0.000000], [901942, 1, 0.000000], [901943, 4, 1.888664], [901944, 3, 0.000000], [901945, 3, 0.000000], [901946, 4, -1.155669], [901947, 1, 0.000000], [901948, 2, 0.000000], [901949, 4, 2.802080], [901950, 1, 0.000000], [901951, 2, 0.000000], [901952, 2, 0.000000], [901953, 4, 0.897528], [901954, 1, 0.000000], [901955, 1, 0.000000], [901956, 2, 0.000000], [901957, 1, 0.000000], [901958, 1, 0.000000], [901959, 3, 0.000000], [901960, 4, 0.693971], [901961, 4, 2.210084], [901962, 3, 0.000000], [901963, 3, 0.000000], [901964, 1, 0.000000], [901965, 4, 5.670330], [901966, 2, 0.000000], [901967, 2, 0.000000], [901968, 1, 0.000000], [901969, 2, 0.000000], [901970, 1, 0.000000], [901971, 3, 0.000000], [901972, 1, 0.000000], [901973, 1, 0.000000], [901974, 2, 0.000000], [901975, 2, 0.000000], [901976, 1, 0.000000], [901977, 1, 0.000000], [901978, 3, 0.000000], [901979, 3, 0.000000], [901980, 2, 0.000000], [901981, 4, 0.177533], [901982, 3, 0.000000], [901983, 1, 0.000000], [901984, 3, 0.000000], [901985, 4, 0.121100], [901986, 4, 1.787302], [901987, 3, 0.000000], [901988, 3, 0.000000], [901989, 4, 0.345225], [901990, 4, 0.560312], [901991, 2, 0.000000], [901992, 1, 0.000000], [901993, 4, 0.228203], [901994, 4, 0.131668], [901995, 3, 0.000000], [901996, 4, 1.670267], [901997, 1, 0.000000], [901998, 4, -2.358266], [901999, 4, 0.614191] ], "worst_seeds": [ { "seed": 901713, "s": 4, "d": -16.437111454599993, "candidate_edge": 55.6097912178, "comparator_edge": 72.0469026724 }, { "seed": 901875, "s": 4, "d": -4.188215439000004, "candidate_edge": -106.7627913643, "comparator_edge": -102.5745759253 }, { "seed": 901910, "s": 4, "d": -3.5235435161000055, "candidate_edge": 319.1311558521, "comparator_edge": 322.6546993682 }, { "seed": 901569, "s": 4, "d": -2.93667514309999, "candidate_edge": 210.9217658586, "comparator_edge": 213.8584410017 }, { "seed": 901928, "s": 4, "d": -2.8121490391000066, "candidate_edge": 62.3703475408, "comparator_edge": 65.1824965799 }, { "seed": 901998, "s": 4, "d": -2.3582656469000085, "candidate_edge": 296.6928429854, "comparator_edge": 299.0511086323 }, { "seed": 901503, "s": 4, "d": -1.6083390791999932, "candidate_edge": 393.664596635, "comparator_edge": 395.2729357142 }, { "seed": 901514, "s": 4, "d": -1.3228557712999987, "candidate_edge": 66.0428464606, "comparator_edge": 67.3657022319 }, { "seed": 901664, "s": 4, "d": -1.1824826622999964, "candidate_edge": 47.9214947167, "comparator_edge": 49.103977379 }, { "seed": 901946, "s": 4, "d": -1.1556693269999982, "candidate_edge": 72.5179849158, "comparator_edge": 73.6736542428 } ], "off_target_zero": true, "notes": "Pinned simulator b244530ee2a6247b5f930830eeca9dd950da0e7e, unmodified defaults, 2000 steps, serial; sample_config and load_strategy_factory called per strategy per seed. Observer records first callback quotes without altering actions. Times cover engine.run only; exclude checks. Statistics use unrounded differences, sample SD/sqrt(n); retail_diff and arb_diff are mean paired differences. No tuning or promotion; this is a 500-seed finalist slice." }