{"key": "s4-f-2", "idea": "finalist measurement: B_RC4 (B_RC + one-tick retreat cancel on spread 4) vs B_RC", "candidate_sha256": "27cef4140f19ecf15aeaa82c8a4bc70f9f066083a5bed10bcb963d8ecbb9b8aa", "comparator_sha256": "02696ea6fd0922f64167a1153748f6a38bf2fd5d87c7a4ac6cb974bb9482f57c", "seeds": {"start": 900500, "end": 900999}, "n": 500, "complete": true, "missing_seeds": [], "failures": [], "check_values": {"310000": 17.512655, "310001": 24.258579, "310002": 2.390311, "310003": 249.541133}, "python_version": "3.12.3", "seconds_per_simulation": {"candidate": {"overall": 0.7279451279640198, "by_spread": {"1": 0.640983640600782, "2": 0.7217445876449347, "3": 0.7530874824523925, "4": 0.7796094538508982}}, "comparator": {"overall": 0.7293034982681275, "by_spread": {"1": 0.6303814638645278, "2": 0.7240672949701548, "3": 0.7482469692230225, "4": 0.7951353961142941}}}, "overall": {"n": 500, "sum_d": 19.421693631300208, "sum_d2": 1038.6099335227273, "mean_diff": 0.038843387262600414, "se": 0.0644960587929409, "comparator_mean": 102.9148174805392, "retail_diff": -0.08218393100839985, "arb_diff": 0.1210273182751999}, "by_spread": {"1": {"n": 109, "sum_d": 0.0, "sum_d2": 0.0, "mean_diff": 0.0, "se": 0.0, "comparator_mean": 25.87433755307615, "retail_diff": 0.0, "arb_diff": 0.0}, "2": {"n": 128, "sum_d": 0.0, "sum_d2": 0.0, "mean_diff": 0.0, "se": 0.0, "comparator_mean": 89.04644495321094, "retail_diff": 0.0, "arb_diff": 0.0}, "3": {"n": 125, "sum_d": 0.0, "sum_d2": 0.0, "mean_diff": 0.0, "se": 0.0, "comparator_mean": 144.3069077042456, "retail_diff": 0.0, "arb_diff": 0.0}, "4": {"n": 138, "sum_d": 19.421693631300208, "sum_d2": 1038.6099335227273, "mean_diff": 0.14073691037174063, "se": 0.23407454144673667, "comparator_mean": 139.1362139850913, "retail_diff": -0.29776786597246324, "arb_diff": 0.4385047763594199}}, "per_seed": [[900500, 3, 0.0], [900501, 1, 0.0], [900502, 2, 0.0], [900503, 1, 0.0], [900504, 1, 0.0], [900505, 4, -1.166931], [900506, 2, 0.0], [900507, 2, 0.0], [900508, 4, -0.809354], [900509, 4, 0.002683], [900510, 1, 0.0], [900511, 3, 0.0], [900512, 1, 0.0], [900513, 4, -2.22364], [900514, 3, 0.0], [900515, 4, 0.597934], [900516, 4, 2.315991], [900517, 1, 0.0], [900518, 2, 0.0], [900519, 2, 0.0], [900520, 4, 0.050861], [900521, 1, 0.0], [900522, 3, 0.0], [900523, 3, 0.0], [900524, 1, 0.0], [900525, 4, 10.077114], [900526, 2, 0.0], [900527, 2, 0.0], [900528, 4, 0.130754], [900529, 1, 0.0], [900530, 4, -0.083306], [900531, 1, 0.0], [900532, 2, 0.0], [900533, 3, 0.0], [900534, 4, 4.550275], [900535, 1, 0.0], [900536, 2, 0.0], [900537, 1, 0.0], [900538, 4, -0.014509], [900539, 3, 0.0], [900540, 4, 0.202082], [900541, 2, 0.0], [900542, 1, 0.0], [900543, 4, 0.002374], [900544, 3, 0.0], [900545, 1, 0.0], [900546, 4, 3.021152], [900547, 4, 0.970752], [900548, 2, 0.0], [900549, 1, 0.0], [900550, 3, 0.0], [900551, 4, 0.079118], [900552, 1, 0.0], [900553, 3, 0.0], [900554, 2, 0.0], [900555, 1, 0.0], [900556, 4, 0.53039], [900557, 2, 0.0], [900558, 3, 0.0], [900559, 4, 0.015576], [900560, 3, 0.0], [900561, 1, 0.0], [900562, 4, 0.39045], [900563, 3, 0.0], [900564, 3, 0.0], [900565, 3, 0.0], [900566, 1, 0.0], [900567, 4, -1.684417], [900568, 4, 0.618276], [900569, 4, -0.246857], [900570, 4, -0.012507], [900571, 4, 0.200772], [900572, 2, 0.0], [900573, 2, 0.0], [900574, 4, 0.106287], [900575, 3, 0.0], [900576, 1, 0.0], [900577, 4, 0.014889], [900578, 4, -0.117479], [900579, 1, 0.0], [900580, 4, 0.465906], [900581, 1, 0.0], [900582, 1, 0.0], [900583, 2, 0.0], [900584, 2, 0.0], [900585, 1, 0.0], [900586, 1, 0.0], [900587, 4, 2.273618], [900588, 3, 0.0], [900589, 3, 0.0], [900590, 1, 0.0], [900591, 4, 3.822973], [900592, 4, 2.390215], [900593, 4, 0.831292], [900594, 3, 0.0], [900595, 2, 0.0], [900596, 2, 0.0], [900597, 2, 0.0], [900598, 1, 0.0], [900599, 1, 0.0], [900600, 2, 0.0], [900601, 4, 5.458162], [900602, 1, 0.0], [900603, 1, 0.0], [900604, 3, 0.0], [900605, 4, -4.317742], [900606, 2, 0.0], [900607, 3, 0.0], [900608, 4, 3.154323], [900609, 2, 0.0], [900610, 4, -1.036282], [900611, 2, 0.0], [900612, 3, 0.0], [900613, 1, 0.0], [900614, 2, 0.0], [900615, 4, 0.406859], [900616, 3, 0.0], [900617, 2, 0.0], [900618, 4, 0.510728], [900619, 1, 0.0], [900620, 3, 0.0], [900621, 1, 0.0], [900622, 4, 1.64621], [900623, 2, 0.0], [900624, 3, 0.0], [900625, 3, 0.0], [900626, 3, 0.0], [900627, 4, 0.160811], [900628, 3, 0.0], [900629, 1, 0.0], [900630, 1, 0.0], [900631, 2, 0.0], [900632, 4, 0.151083], [900633, 4, 0.717955], [900634, 2, 0.0], [900635, 4, -8.416867], [900636, 4, 5.164673], [900637, 2, 0.0], [900638, 4, 0.098668], [900639, 4, -5.724843], [900640, 4, 2.058047], [900641, 4, -0.949644], [900642, 4, -0.384552], [900643, 1, 0.0], [900644, 3, 0.0], [900645, 2, 0.0], [900646, 4, 0.039492], [900647, 1, 0.0], [900648, 3, 0.0], [900649, 2, 0.0], [900650, 1, 0.0], [900651, 1, 0.0], [900652, 3, 0.0], [900653, 3, 0.0], [900654, 1, 0.0], [900655, 2, 0.0], [900656, 3, 0.0], [900657, 2, 0.0], [900658, 1, 0.0], [900659, 2, 0.0], [900660, 3, 0.0], [900661, 3, 0.0], [900662, 3, 0.0], [900663, 2, 0.0], [900664, 4, 0.060599], [900665, 1, 0.0], [900666, 2, 0.0], [900667, 3, 0.0], [900668, 4, 0.766762], [900669, 3, 0.0], [900670, 4, 1.225342], [900671, 4, 0.021397], [900672, 4, 0.022504], [900673, 2, 0.0], [900674, 4, -0.196977], [900675, 3, 0.0], [900676, 2, 0.0], [900677, 2, 0.0], [900678, 1, 0.0], [900679, 2, 0.0], [900680, 1, 0.0], [900681, 2, 0.0], [900682, 2, 0.0], [900683, 4, 0.182024], [900684, 3, 0.0], [900685, 4, 0.522718], [900686, 4, 0.010831], [900687, 4, 0.090165], [900688, 2, 0.0], [900689, 3, 0.0], [900690, 3, 0.0], [900691, 2, 0.0], [900692, 1, 0.0], [900693, 1, 0.0], [900694, 3, 0.0], [900695, 4, 0.040587], [900696, 1, 0.0], [900697, 3, 0.0], [900698, 3, 0.0], [900699, 2, 0.0], [900700, 4, -1.307889], [900701, 2, 0.0], [900702, 2, 0.0], [900703, 3, 0.0], [900704, 3, 0.0], [900705, 2, 0.0], [900706, 3, 0.0], [900707, 4, -0.890489], [900708, 2, 0.0], [900709, 2, 0.0], [900710, 3, 0.0], [900711, 3, 0.0], [900712, 1, 0.0], [900713, 4, 0.005929], [900714, 4, 1.063332], [900715, 2, 0.0], [900716, 4, -0.422934], [900717, 2, 0.0], [900718, 2, 0.0], [900719, 3, 0.0], [900720, 3, 0.0], [900721, 2, 0.0], [900722, 1, 0.0], [900723, 1, 0.0], [900724, 4, 0.220988], [900725, 4, 0.187582], [900726, 3, 0.0], [900727, 3, 0.0], [900728, 2, 0.0], [900729, 2, 0.0], [900730, 2, 0.0], [900731, 3, 0.0], [900732, 1, 0.0], [900733, 3, 0.0], [900734, 1, 0.0], [900735, 4, 0.483468], [900736, 3, 0.0], [900737, 4, 0.279825], [900738, 3, 0.0], [900739, 4, -21.490429], [900740, 4, 3.870087], [900741, 2, 0.0], [900742, 2, 0.0], [900743, 2, 0.0], [900744, 2, 0.0], [900745, 2, 0.0], [900746, 1, 0.0], [900747, 3, 0.0], [900748, 2, 0.0], [900749, 4, -0.351551], [900750, 2, 0.0], [900751, 4, 0.468752], [900752, 3, 0.0], [900753, 3, 0.0], [900754, 2, 0.0], [900755, 1, 0.0], [900756, 4, 2.259364], [900757, 4, 0.867985], [900758, 3, 0.0], [900759, 4, -0.940618], [900760, 2, 0.0], [900761, 1, 0.0], [900762, 4, 2.450048], [900763, 2, 0.0], [900764, 2, 0.0], [900765, 2, 0.0], [900766, 1, 0.0], [900767, 1, 0.0], [900768, 4, 0.211054], [900769, 2, 0.0], [900770, 2, 0.0], [900771, 3, 0.0], [900772, 2, 0.0], [900773, 2, 0.0], [900774, 3, 0.0], [900775, 3, 0.0], [900776, 3, 0.0], [900777, 4, -5.575536], [900778, 3, 0.0], [900779, 3, 0.0], [900780, 2, 0.0], [900781, 3, 0.0], [900782, 3, 0.0], [900783, 2, 0.0], [900784, 4, 0.191734], [900785, 1, 0.0], [900786, 3, 0.0], [900787, 3, 0.0], [900788, 4, -2.286452], [900789, 2, 0.0], [900790, 4, 0.043397], [900791, 4, 2.776895], [900792, 3, 0.0], [900793, 4, 0.309109], [900794, 1, 0.0], [900795, 3, 0.0], [900796, 2, 0.0], [900797, 1, 0.0], [900798, 1, 0.0], [900799, 2, 0.0], [900800, 1, 0.0], [900801, 1, 0.0], [900802, 2, 0.0], [900803, 2, 0.0], [900804, 2, 0.0], [900805, 2, 0.0], [900806, 3, 0.0], [900807, 1, 0.0], [900808, 1, 0.0], [900809, 1, 0.0], [900810, 1, 0.0], [900811, 2, 0.0], [900812, 3, 0.0], [900813, 4, 2.472047], [900814, 3, 0.0], [900815, 4, 0.239479], [900816, 2, 0.0], [900817, 3, 0.0], [900818, 2, 0.0], [900819, 3, 0.0], [900820, 3, 0.0], [900821, 1, 0.0], [900822, 2, 0.0], [900823, 3, 0.0], [900824, 2, 0.0], [900825, 2, 0.0], [900826, 2, 0.0], [900827, 2, 0.0], [900828, 4, 0.459151], [900829, 1, 0.0], [900830, 2, 0.0], [900831, 1, 0.0], [900832, 3, 0.0], [900833, 4, 3.208504], [900834, 4, -0.551505], [900835, 4, -4.265646], [900836, 4, -0.309286], [900837, 4, -0.194928], [900838, 2, 0.0], [900839, 4, -1.551466], [900840, 1, 0.0], [900841, 3, 0.0], [900842, 2, 0.0], [900843, 2, 0.0], [900844, 2, 0.0], [900845, 3, 0.0], [900846, 1, 0.0], [900847, 1, 0.0], [900848, 1, 0.0], [900849, 3, 0.0], [900850, 2, 0.0], [900851, 2, 0.0], [900852, 2, 0.0], [900853, 4, 0.392182], [900854, 4, 0.270352], [900855, 1, 0.0], [900856, 4, 1.555], [900857, 3, 0.0], [900858, 2, 0.0], [900859, 2, 0.0], [900860, 3, 0.0], [900861, 1, 0.0], [900862, 4, 0.070202], [900863, 2, 0.0], [900864, 3, 0.0], [900865, 4, -0.564702], [900866, 3, 0.0], [900867, 4, 0.051257], [900868, 3, 0.0], [900869, 3, 0.0], [900870, 1, 0.0], [900871, 2, 0.0], [900872, 1, 0.0], [900873, 4, -0.638605], [900874, 3, 0.0], [900875, 1, 0.0], [900876, 1, 0.0], [900877, 4, 0.179113], [900878, 4, 0.097818], [900879, 3, 0.0], [900880, 2, 0.0], [900881, 1, 0.0], [900882, 1, 0.0], [900883, 4, -2.544368], [900884, 4, 1.460893], [900885, 4, 0.832066], [900886, 3, 0.0], [900887, 1, 0.0], [900888, 2, 0.0], [900889, 4, 2.162869], [900890, 3, 0.0], [900891, 1, 0.0], [900892, 2, 0.0], [900893, 2, 0.0], [900894, 2, 0.0], [900895, 1, 0.0], [900896, 3, 0.0], [900897, 1, 0.0], [900898, 3, 0.0], [900899, 4, 1.331825], [900900, 4, 3.695133], [900901, 4, -1.626403], [900902, 2, 0.0], [900903, 2, 0.0], [900904, 4, 0.287554], [900905, 1, 0.0], [900906, 3, 0.0], [900907, 4, 0.869813], [900908, 4, 0.404537], [900909, 4, 0.307005], [900910, 3, 0.0], [900911, 4, -0.374612], [900912, 4, -0.964077], [900913, 2, 0.0], [900914, 2, 0.0], [900915, 4, -6.349996], [900916, 4, 0.75919], [900917, 3, 0.0], [900918, 4, 0.67783], [900919, 4, 0.11041], [900920, 1, 0.0], [900921, 3, 0.0], [900922, 3, 0.0], [900923, 4, 1.052643], [900924, 4, 0.164365], [900925, 2, 0.0], [900926, 1, 0.0], [900927, 2, 0.0], [900928, 4, -0.173605], [900929, 1, 0.0], [900930, 3, 0.0], [900931, 4, 0.137472], [900932, 2, 0.0], [900933, 1, 0.0], [900934, 4, 0.002193], [900935, 2, 0.0], [900936, 1, 0.0], [900937, 3, 0.0], [900938, 3, 0.0], [900939, 3, 0.0], [900940, 1, 0.0], [900941, 1, 0.0], [900942, 3, 0.0], [900943, 1, 0.0], [900944, 2, 0.0], [900945, 3, 0.0], [900946, 4, 0.29088], [900947, 3, 0.0], [900948, 3, 0.0], [900949, 1, 0.0], [900950, 3, 0.0], [900951, 2, 0.0], [900952, 4, 1.879393], [900953, 4, 0.10043], [900954, 3, 0.0], [900955, 1, 0.0], [900956, 4, 0.106426], [900957, 2, 0.0], [900958, 3, 0.0], [900959, 4, 0.153569], [900960, 4, -0.197056], [900961, 3, 0.0], [900962, 2, 0.0], [900963, 2, 0.0], [900964, 1, 0.0], [900965, 3, 0.0], [900966, 4, 0.057068], [900967, 1, 0.0], [900968, 1, 0.0], [900969, 1, 0.0], [900970, 4, 0.953468], [900971, 1, 0.0], [900972, 3, 0.0], [900973, 3, 0.0], [900974, 2, 0.0], [900975, 2, 0.0], [900976, 3, 0.0], [900977, 2, 0.0], [900978, 3, 0.0], [900979, 3, 0.0], [900980, 3, 0.0], [900981, 1, 0.0], [900982, 4, 0.061797], [900983, 2, 0.0], [900984, 4, 0.953817], [900985, 4, 0.087806], [900986, 2, 0.0], [900987, 3, 0.0], [900988, 2, 0.0], [900989, 3, 0.0], [900990, 1, 0.0], [900991, 1, 0.0], [900992, 3, 0.0], [900993, 1, 0.0], [900994, 1, 0.0], [900995, 3, 0.0], [900996, 2, 0.0], [900997, 1, 0.0], [900998, 4, 0.622978], [900999, 1, 0.0]], "worst_seeds": [{"seed": 900739, "s": 4, "d": -21.490429, "candidate_edge": 437.6391111848, "comparator_edge": 459.129539902}, {"seed": 900635, "s": 4, "d": -8.416867, "candidate_edge": 516.9287432688, "comparator_edge": 525.3456101486}, {"seed": 900915, "s": 4, "d": -6.349996, "candidate_edge": 645.5351992985, "comparator_edge": 651.8851955746}, {"seed": 900639, "s": 4, "d": -5.724843, "candidate_edge": 50.1247120409, "comparator_edge": 55.8495555259}, {"seed": 900777, "s": 4, "d": -5.575536, "candidate_edge": 559.1373936743, "comparator_edge": 564.7129296968}, {"seed": 900605, "s": 4, "d": -4.317742, "candidate_edge": 163.6023409967, "comparator_edge": 167.9200831048}, {"seed": 900835, "s": 4, "d": -4.265646, "candidate_edge": 223.7464006644, "comparator_edge": 228.0120468372}, {"seed": 900883, "s": 4, "d": -2.544368, "candidate_edge": 219.3110181293, "comparator_edge": 221.8553865883}, {"seed": 900788, "s": 4, "d": -2.286452, "candidate_edge": 93.8335302306, "comparator_edge": 96.1199818805}, {"seed": 900513, "s": 4, "d": -2.22364, "candidate_edge": 512.6520397934, "comparator_edge": 514.8756799817}], "off_target_zero": true, "notes": "All 3 SHA-256 verified; K check values match B_RC's. Unmodified simulator at b244530, default config, single process, chunks of 50. Overall mean_diff 0.0388 se 0.0645; spread 4 n=138 mean 0.1407 se 0.2341. off_target_zero=True. s taken from first on_step state competitor quotes."}