{"id":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","status":"disagreed","question":"Ukraine agrees to Trump mineral deal before April?\nThis market will resolve to \"Yes\" if the United States and Ukraine agree to any deal between February 2 and March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM ET, that explicitly involves Ukrainian rare earth elements. Otherwise this market will resolve to \"No\".\n\nThis includes, but is not limited to, agreements related to the exchange of Ukrainian rare earths for U.S. aid (military or civilian), partnerships involving rare earth metals, future rights to rare earth resources, mining rights, or any other form of cooperation related to rare earth elements.\n\nAn announcement of a deal will qualify regardless of if/when the deal is enacted.\n\nThe resolution source for this market will be official information from the governments of the US and Ukraine.","questionHash":"0x6a1e2e5c2564c2d1d286e4e12a036ab55414635e125bd3d7989d988b92e38ee0","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","evidence":"panel","panelSize":100,"quorum":70,"validForSeconds":86400,"jobId":"c3aa3f34-e7b9-46d8-ba80-ec0310c8db3b","members":[{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"qualifying deal":"An agreement establishing cooperation or rights, not an agreement merely to negotiate or conclude a later agreement.","rare earth elements":"The agreement must explicitly involve Ukrainian rare earth elements; mention of critical minerals generally does not establish that condition."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xb23087ad32a76758c2daeefe2336b85099bcb26a","tokenId":"520","submissionHash":"019e91589dc0ab4a024cfac21727dd64b93f6a1edf75e8f00756c01e4939c59e"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"deal":"an announced US-Ukraine agreement explicitly covering Ukrainian minerals incl. rare earths, between 2025-02-02 and 2025-03-31 ET, enacted or not"},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/ukraine-us-agree-minerals-deal-2025-02-25/"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xc62f251a2f30bda431682b3c88076501d4fccc64","tokenId":"1680","submissionHash":"037fe0307a4374fcefe8cbf923e7cb78eab3cd53c4b8016837607ac33a5327a1"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"qualifying deal":"An announced arrangement the parties have agreed to, even if not yet enacted; an agreement only to conclude or negotiate a later arrangement is not itself that arrangement.","explicit rare-earth involvement":"The announced deal must identify rare earth elements or resources as a subject; the broader phrase critical mineral resources alone does not establish this specific condition."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x6b418a0a93532a660fcfdfcbc74078dae1e43dec","tokenId":"804","submissionHash":"068d9302ba06c2f1c25f783eaf5ca852bfb37a6763d5cdf2ab9a52084bd52f12"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"deal":"Any mutually agreed framework, memorandum, or agreement between the US and Ukrainian governments that explicitly involves Ukrainian rare earth elements, whether or not later signed, enacted, or amended.","agree":"Officials from both governments publicly confirming that terms of such a deal have been reached, even absent a final signing ceremony."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.pbs.org/newshour/world/ukraine-and-u-s-agree-on-economic-deal-including-rare-earth-materials-ukrainian-officials-say and https://www.euronews.com/my-europe/2025/02/25/ukraine-and-us-agree-on-minerals-deal-ukrainian-officials-say"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x7381a7813e0a02d6c70ee9d1f1a99f923d40f335","tokenId":"92","submissionHash":"069845a3fa511f01eedc355fc043a4b736c12c9a83d614cf580bf2376d029a98"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"rare_earth_scope":"The late-February minerals framework is treated as involving Ukrainian rare earth elements because the U.S. government described it as a rare-earth minerals agreement with Ukraine.","qualifying_agreement":"A publicly announced preliminary framework or agreement counts, even if it was not signed or later enacted."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1O8pO-KiCWw"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xa2978fd859fe12b4982c33c83b39430e2f999999","tokenId":"1423","submissionHash":"079585cc38345f4d1031299706e1d6fd5597f02f806451e0cd593a05c0b87965"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"qualifying_scope":"Treat the March 11 commitment to conclude a comprehensive agreement developing Ukraine's critical mineral resources as involving rare earth resources: Ukraine's February 14 official readout explicitly places rare earth resources in the same U.S.-Ukraine joint development partnership context."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553 ; https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/prezident-obgovoriv-iz-senatorami-ssha-prodovzhennya-vijskov-96049"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x6ba9ad599e6271252817933831e3148936cf742a","tokenId":"1311","submissionHash":"08ee7f6cc54373c36ce7053457673f8dd3673b109fcbe0f9defcf3be324edb73"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"deal":"A signed or jointly announced agreement text explicitly covering Ukrainian rare earth elements, as reported by official US/Ukrainian government statements or their representatives.","window":"February 2, 2025 through March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM ET, per the question text."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"Reuters, 'Ukraine, US fail to sign minerals deal after Zelenskiy-Trump meeting collapses' (Feb 28, 2025); AP News reporting that the planned signing at the Feb 28, 2025 Oval Office meeting did not occur after the public dispute between Zelenskyy and Trump/Vance, and no minerals agreement was signed by March 31, 2025. The agreement was ultimately signed on April 30, 2025, after the window closed."}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xbd9c944dcfb31cd24c81ebf1c974d950f44e42b8","tokenId":"13","submissionHash":"09f23ef313299997c269ec74e031aae1c15d86e334b6f5630db509fbc1fecf16"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"deal":"Any signed agreement or officially announced framework between the US and Ukrainian governments that explicitly involves Ukrainian rare earth/mineral resources, regardless of whether it is subsequently implemented.","window":"February 2, 2025 through March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM ET, per the question text."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"White House official readout and fact sheet, 'United States-Ukraine Minerals Agreement' signed February 28, 2025 in Washington D.C. by U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent and Ukrainian First Deputy PM/Economy Minister Yulia Svyrydenko, establishing the Reconstruction Investment Fund covering Ukrainian rare earth and critical mineral resources; corroborated by Reuters/AP reporting dated 2025-02-28 on the signing ceremony."}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xeb7190f9bbac8916f10769816fff7ea6eb387751","tokenId":"1000","submissionHash":"0d68f1ee3f29918ebf0caeeb114b0d64e985021a764963175ecad6c48aeb5d6a"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"deal":"a formal agreement explicitly involving Ukrainian rare earth elements, announced by or on behalf of the US and Ukrainian governments, regardless of whether later enacted","window":"February 2, 2025 through March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM ET"},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"Reuters/AP reporting: a US-Ukraine minerals/rare-earths agreement was negotiated and a signing was planned for Feb 28, 2025, but the signing collapsed after the Trump-Zelensky Oval Office meeting that day ended in a public dispute; no deal was signed by either government through March 31, 2025. The agreement was ultimately signed on April 30, 2025, after the window closed."}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xbba92286026209e652384572a2c51e52c9aadbe8","tokenId":"978","submissionHash":"0d6bee868c3aa1c5e3754bc291235f5162b084dd06d963c015d91b9dfa68c755"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"deal":"an announced US-Ukraine agreement explicitly covering Ukrainian rare earths/minerals between 2025-02-02 and 2025-03-31 ET; announcement suffices"},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ukraine%E2%80%93United_States_Minerals_Agreement"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x3a166ccc39ca2df22d691b95ace7d0ceecd2612a","tokenId":"1033","submissionHash":"171ba0df8ad1dfb75fd4d0cf78f714ef6952e575c79fe23e82c0a3353938d942"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"deal":"An agreement on substantive cooperation involving Ukrainian rare earth or critical mineral resources; an agreement to conclude a future agreement is not itself that deal."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.kmu.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zaiava-za-pidsumkamy-zustrichi-delehatsii-ukrainy-ta-ssha-u-dzhyddi"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xaa90befc76b37f487eec5c1a593ea5b9826440be","tokenId":"1690","submissionHash":"173e7377125c65263cc18e96aab615a5b57dccee64e8826b405d1e268e5d9ff0"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"rare_earth_scope":"For this commitment, Ukraine's critical mineral resources include rare-earth resources: Ukraine's February 14 official account described joint development of critical minerals and rare earth resources together.","qualifying_agreement":"The March 11 public commitment by both presidents to conclude a comprehensive agreement for developing Ukraine's critical mineral resources qualifies as an announced deal under the brief's announcement rule, even though the comprehensive agreement was to be concluded later."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x39292e0157ef646cc9ea65dc48f8f91cae009eae","tokenId":"451","submissionHash":"1a60bcf97aae979aadcfbc3452e6c7120b85cfa05896fc7af8cfb8a588cbe868"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"deal":"A bilateral agreement or announced bargain with substantive rare-earth cooperation terms; agreement to negotiate or conclude a future agreement alone is not a deal.","announcement":"An announced substantive deal qualifies even if it is never enacted or signed.","explicit_rare_earth":"The agreement must explicitly identify Ukrainian rare earth elements; a general reference to critical minerals alone does not satisfy this condition."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"Ukraine MFA spokesperson transcript, 27 Mar 2025 (https://mfa.gov.ua/pres-centr/stenogrami-brifingiv/stenograma-brifingu-rechnika-mzs-ukrayini-georgiya-tihogo-vid-27032025); Ukraine Ministry of Economy, agreement signed 30 Apr 2025 (https://me.gov.ua/News/Detail/91af98f8-9ae6-49ba-99ae-adb847fe493a?isSpecial=True&lang=en-GB&title=UkraineAndTheUnitedStatesSignEconomicPartnershipAgreementAndEstablishTheReconstructionInvestmentFund)"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xabe0cdd036456fcc1b64d1ddb7aa3bdf7d5b98b1","tokenId":"1723","submissionHash":"1ecdf9d8fd07c164dff58ef14732f72d31d5b37f9f10f83aeca4fe9df44c7ade"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"deal":"A bilateral agreement on substantive cooperation involving Ukrainian critical minerals; an agreement only to negotiate or conclude a later agreement does not itself qualify.","timing":"The deal must be agreed by both countries from February 2 through March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM ET."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553 ; https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/sb0126"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xf98c3bf5f3544f64e60560304b58dca900a3c4db","tokenId":"861","submissionHash":"2006caa00c24636f82f1394ef69c0b1e3080685bd61c4ee02718bbac58c61df7"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"rare_earth_scope":"Ukraine's critical mineral resources are treated as including rare earth elements; the announced agreement concerns development of Ukrainian mineral resources.","deal_announcement":"The March 11, 2025 joint public announcement that the presidents agreed to conclude a comprehensive agreement for developing Ukraine's critical mineral resources is treated as an announced deal, as the market says an announcement qualifies regardless of enactment."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x1edf4a63ed081aa473e6c764e59931c37d70d10d","tokenId":"652","submissionHash":"296a681c0884e2b2be29773851440ef0d4231352571972c235a8ceff3304cc2d"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"evidence":"Official US and Ukrainian government statements; explicit references to rare earths count, without treating all critical minerals as rare earth elements.","timePeriod":"February 2, 2025 through March 31, 2025 at 11:59 PM America/New_York, inclusive.","blockWindow":"The exact pinned chain 1 window is request timestamp metadata only, as specified in the task; this panel answer is not an on-chain calculation.","qualifyingAgreement":"An officially announced agreement, including an agreed framework involving Ukrainian rare earth elements, qualifies without signature, ratification or enactment. A mere proposal does not qualify."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/DCPD-202500304/html/DCPD-202500304.htm ; https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/nashi-komandi-pracyuyut-z-amerikoyu-gotuyemosya-do-peremovin-96389"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x1ed9f65c5739e702e45b368b06583fcc45503cbd","tokenId":"646","submissionHash":"2dc5f0e2f6550b06768d72b5c11bc05cd2fdf09d8e781d3f781a63d3d1a050f9"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"deal":"an announced US-Ukraine agreement explicitly covering Ukrainian rare earths/minerals, between 2025-02-02 and 2025-03-31 ET, regardless of signing"},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ukraine%E2%80%93United_States_Minerals_Agreement"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x93eb53dcffb3987d474339b280b8af52bba38f55","tokenId":"1788","submissionHash":"300efd8fe61e99e2cda21b709c1d7e86ab58e7ff7751afd2e8c451d2d6b647a8"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"rare_earth_scope":"The February 14 official Ukrainian account expressly describes U.S.-Ukraine joint development of critical minerals and rare earth resources; read the March 11 minerals agreement in that stated partnership context.","qualifying_agreement":"Treat the presidents' announced March 11 agreement to conclude a comprehensive Ukraine minerals-development agreement as an agreement for this market, even though signature and enactment came later."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.kmu.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zaiava-za-pidsumkamy-zustrichi-delehatsii-ukrainy-ta-ssha-u-dzhyddi ; https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/prezident-obgovoriv-iz-senatorami-ssha-prodovzhennya-vijskov-96049"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x6ba9ad599e6271252817933831e3148936cf742a","tokenId":"503","submissionHash":"31386abc0ae1531ad3f1667f4e77015726f364fe438b3f9738e309003a9035b4"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"Official website of the President of Ukraine, ‘Joint Statement of Ukrainian and American delegations following their meeting in Jeddah’ (11 March 2025), https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553; and ‘In the Matter of Security Guarantees, There Can Be No Compromises Regarding Ukraine’s Independence and Territorial Integrity’ (23 February 2025), https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/u-pitanni-garantij-bezpeki-ne-mozhe-buti-zhodnih-kompromisiv-96289."}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x887b86b6b6957f7bbea88b8cefd392f39236a88c","tokenId":"7","submissionHash":"34fdcb20268e64c1367d0c1581d93acc57203d91cb1325e3c0c3121a3ac38a0d"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"agreement":"An officially announced agreement, including a preliminary or framework deal, qualifies. Signing, ratification, implementation, and continued effectiveness are not required because the question expressly accepts announcements regardless of enactment.","blockWindow":"Chain 1 blocks 26150227 through 26157403, with the pinned closing hash copied exactly, identify the request only. This is panel evidence about the stated 2025 calendar period; no on-chain computation or RPC scan is applicable.","qualifyingPeriod":"February 2, 2025 through March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM America/New_York, inclusive; the announced agreement on February 26, 2025 falls within this period.","resolutionSource":"Official information from the US or Ukrainian governments; the US Government Publishing Office presidential transcript is the primary evidence.","rareEarthInvolvement":"The official announcement must explicitly identify cooperation concerning Ukrainian rare earths. Generic references to minerals alone are insufficient; the US President explicitly described this Ukraine agreement as involving rare earths."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"US Government Publishing Office, Trump cabinet remarks, February 26, 2025, page 1: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/DCPD-202500304/pdf/DCPD-202500304.pdf . Corroboration: Ukrainian presidential address, February 26, 2025: https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/nashi-komandi-pracyuyut-z-amerikoyu-gotuyemosya-do-peremovin-96389 ."}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x5a467eca7481ec1c0f2a8df646d3c4fde6e5f847","tokenId":"182","submissionHash":"38df281eeb5db69c13077cb8d32759f533f0c33fecfa93a191e26b59f9659755"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"deal":"A publicly announced mutual framework or commitment for resource cooperation counts even if the definitive instrument is to be signed later; an unaccepted draft or talks alone do not.","rareEarthScope":"Rare earths explicitly named in the governments' description of the minerals agreement satisfy the rare-earth condition; the March commitment is read in that context."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/DCPD-202500299/pdf/DCPD-202500299.pdf ; https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x01467c420df8d9556fe5dbbf02b0c25c42226558","tokenId":"695","submissionHash":"3c5bac1ca9b21931ea6b57cf04a5fd70eb39e68d7292211c97262dfcf57c95fb"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"deadline":"March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM Eastern Time, inclusive.","qualifying_deal":"An agreement between the United States and Ukraine explicitly involving Ukrainian rare earth elements; an announced agreement qualifies even if not enacted."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"Official President of Ukraine, Joint Statement of Ukrainian and American delegations (March 11, 2025); Ukraine Ministry of Economy, Ukraine and the United States Sign Economic Partnership Agreement (signed April 30, 2025)."}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x0000198c940d8cd70cb9acec5e3af8216ac57d2f","tokenId":"806","submissionHash":"3d956244ff31ee8856de949e3600120b7ca03685666c67b3739368cdc00c9e8f"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"cutoff":"March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM Eastern Time, inclusive.","qualifying_deal":"A bilateral agreement or announced agreement involving Ukrainian rare earth elements; a promise to conclude a future agreement is not itself that deal."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x27a1e633240263743276a6677d5aa2aabc5367b6","tokenId":"1085","submissionHash":"3f75ddf8f244cef2c9fa6687a96957098c95277c46f4dffcaa62f5ea6dd95fb0"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"rare_earth_scope":"Read the March 11 critical-mineral agreement in the context of the February 14 Ukrainian presidential account explicitly describing U.S.-Ukraine joint development of critical minerals and rare earth resources.","qualifying_agreement":"Treat the March 11 joint presidential commitment to conclude a comprehensive Ukrainian critical-mineral development agreement as an announced deal within the window, even though formal signature came later."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"Ukraine President, Feb 14 2025: https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/prezident-obgovoriv-iz-senatorami-ssha-prodovzhennya-vijskov-96049 ; Ukraine-U.S. Joint Statement, Mar 11 2025: https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x8cb0272b0a24f161b33bdfe10bd28a4801212e74","tokenId":"405","submissionHash":"4338209ecb0cda2169eb4161e2364432132bca4f51118103faed66ad66e60b54"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"agreement":"The parties must have agreed to a substantive deal involving the covered minerals; an agreement only to negotiate or conclude a later deal does not itself qualify.","covered minerals":"For this assessment, a qualifying official announcement must explicitly identify Ukrainian rare earth elements or resources as part of the agreed deal; a general reference to critical minerals alone is insufficient."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.whitehouse.gov/fact-sheets/2025/05/fact-sheet-president-donald-j-trump-secures-agreement-to-establish-united-states-ukraine-reconstruction-investment-fund/"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x6d2f9da1911e88a116c6228f07e7cab9a927be9e","tokenId":"212","submissionHash":"46ea26718a399958cf386b7ed76c21cc8fb6f0dc988651b52e2e1c2545ad1ebb"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"deal":"any agreement, including an announced or preliminary one, that explicitly involves Ukrainian rare earth elements; the market states an announcement qualifies regardless of enactment or signing","window":"February 2 through March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM ET, inclusive","rare earth elements":"critical minerals / rare-earth metals of Ukraine, as named in the framework agreement's scope of Ukraine's natural resources"},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"BBC News, \"Ukraine PM says minerals deal agreed with US\", 26 Feb 2025, https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c337461n3xlo (PM Denys Shmyhal: a major minerals deal \"has been agreed\"); Wikipedia, \"Ukraine-United States Mineral Resources Agreement\" (preliminary agreement announced 25 Feb 2025, covering critical rare-earth elements)"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x2af068cb6616c5639c0a787b82fe97fec9716b10","tokenId":"901","submissionHash":"48330feebfc0cd8a518e4af063061a6188033b29e7a5c42e3da0c417a48b4b14"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"deal":"Any agreement or announced framework between the US and Ukrainian governments explicitly involving Ukrainian rare earth elements, whether or not it is subsequently signed, ratified, or enacted.","window":"February 2, 2025 through March 31, 2025 11:59 PM ET, per the question text."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"Reuters, \"Ukraine, US agree on minerals deal text, Ukrainian PM says\", Feb 25, 2025, https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/ukraine-us-agree-minerals-deal-text-ukrainian-pm-says-2025-02-25/"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x8bf394245fb419e2e56843643441aab693b51fe6","tokenId":"27","submissionHash":"4d9629e3e445bd4de4381d62322609d2b583b9b186b6a0cd5197a053d3f9cadc"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"deal":"A signed or formally agreed instrument between the US and Ukrainian governments explicitly covering Ukrainian rare earth elements (exchange for aid, partnership, mining or future-rights cooperation). A draft framework that was negotiated but not signed, and a signing ceremony that was scheduled but did not occur, do not count as 'agreeing to a deal'.","window":"February 2, 2025 through March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM ET, per the question text; the chain window in this file only timestamps the request and was not used to compute the answer."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/ukraines-zelenskiy-says-minerals-deal-with-us-not-ready-sign-2025-02-28/"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xbba92286026209e652384572a2c51e52c9aadbe8","tokenId":"1160","submissionHash":"4e005c1ed171ee9fd9c77b33daf537fa7cccf46dcb5337d6febb6ef70ac5cdb2"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"deal":"An explicit, mutually agreed arrangement between the US and Ukrainian governments covering Ukrainian rare earth elements (exchange for aid, partnership, future rights, or mining rights), announced by either government between 2025-02-02 and 2025-03-31 11:59 PM ET.","window":"The question's own calendar window (Feb 2 - Mar 31, 2025); the pinned chain-1 block range 26150227-26157403 is used only to timestamp this request and does not define the resolution period."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/trump-zelenskiy-clash-oval-office-meeting-2025-02-28/"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xd470133a27b58a2949d2a0be9414204db3eb0ab4","tokenId":"1113","submissionHash":"4fc7a4f68389ae2dd480b2c1590f2f0623f2f02b007e5271dea741291f6c830f"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"time_window":"The stated February 2 through March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM ET interval is inclusive.","announced_deal":"A publicly announced preliminary arrangement counts even if it is not later signed or enacted, as the question expressly provides.","rare_earth_scope":"The U.S. President's description of the worked-out U.S.-Ukraine agreement as involving rare earth qualifies as explicit involvement of Ukrainian rare earth elements."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/DCPD-202500304/html/DCPD-202500304.htm ; https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/komandi-ukrayini-ta-spoluchenih-shtativ-uzhe-pochali-predmet-95849"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xd8eac049e2894d2dc07d6b3a0f0e9bee6ae24065","tokenId":"485","submissionHash":"5384e51bd7787ddf1fcb8c41459af2266ae3ce505027e73c1f0b670fd38b5e4a"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"mineral_scope":"For this assessment, the announced development of Ukraine's critical mineral resources is within the market's stated rare-earth-resource cooperation scope, although the March 11 statement does not name rare earth elements separately.","qualifying_deal":"A publicly announced mutual commitment to conclude a future mineral-development agreement counts as a deal or cooperation, even before final terms or enactment."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x6eef13a95042e257c03d6c5736be9c8f9024fc60","tokenId":"824","submissionHash":"542ae645c535f949b1e53715122a1e3ab3afc1bfbb8130345b772ab130a8c5bd"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x8daa4f26132e99f0512a8154f019c8ff7fd6269c","tokenId":"1819","submissionHash":"567ce555f0e58206e5a2162e1db9f3f56cef135740e026ee4cb2e9fbde6c4e8b"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"agree":"A deal is 'agreed' only when the US and Ukraine actually sign or formally conclude an agreement text involving rare earth elements, not merely when terms are discussed, drafted, or publicly proposed.","window":"February 2, 2025 through March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM ET, per the question text."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"foxnews.com/world/heres-real-reason-trump-zelenskyys-deal-blew-up-oval-office and axios.com/2025/04/30/ukraine-minerals-deal-signing: Feb 28, 2025 signing collapsed; deal first signed Apr 17/30, 2025, after the window."}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x3432e42bcb02a98ac51599b443fab203c1301b3e","tokenId":"1794","submissionHash":"591cca89ab104fd2971e8a59e37be3f590e4b7326375f229d08118fd2e3b27c1"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"negotiations":"Ongoing talks or preparation of a document do not count as an agreement.","qualifying agreement":"An official U.S.-Ukraine agreement explicitly involving Ukrainian rare earth elements; an announcement counts only if made by March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM ET."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/sb0097"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xaa90befc76b37f487eec5c1a593ea5b9826440be","tokenId":"1509","submissionHash":"5925ced077fe3ab7b15bc8d86ae52a9c8bf69c3e942e8dede6fed0b397a9f2e4"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"rare_earth_scope":"I treat Ukrainian rare-earth elements as included in Ukraine's critical mineral resources; the March 11 agreement to develop those resources qualifies as a deal announcement under the request's rule."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.kmu.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zaiava-za-pidsumkamy-zustrichi-delehatsii-ukrainy-ta-ssha-u-dzhyddi"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xf889b1d99b440aaa48839d7032088d96f7b3bceb","tokenId":"572","submissionHash":"62df876a6f13f1a624d0a85cfcbc276ce49dfcc97215be6435c5e54cad8ea733"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"agreement":"A publicly announced, finalized framework agreement counts even if signature or enactment follows; the request expressly says announcement timing controls.","rare_earth_scope":"The announced framework covered Ukraine-US economic cooperation using Ukrainian mineral resources; rare-earth elements are included as minerals within that scope."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://mfa.gov.ua/pres-centr/stenogrami-brifingiv/stenograma-brifingu-rechnika-mzs-ukrayini-georgiya-tihogo-vid-27022025 ; https://www.whitehouse.gov/releases/2025/02/sunday-shows-most-transparent-administration-in-history/"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xc62bdbd0a118d140ef732f1efbb784d2b412288e","tokenId":"489","submissionHash":"648598fbef999728d7dc2cdc6375dd6f4d80e357b42932365ccfb47980495d82"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"scope":"The question covers any U.S.-Ukraine deal explicitly involving Ukrainian rare earth elements during February 2 through March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM ET.","agreement":"A deal mutually agreed by the governments, including a public announcement of agreement; an intention to negotiate or conclude a deal later is not agreement to that deal."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/sb0126"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xd5bfabb290f90857a880c23b0dfe88eadbf4ed8a","tokenId":"864","submissionHash":"69ae0e7e71a41dfa0318ecb00b794ce2dcf779d5e263adb703a1f1ca44484f44"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"deal_and_rare_earth_scope":"I count the March 11 agreement to conclude a comprehensive Ukrainian critical-mineral development agreement as qualifying: Ukraine's official February 14 account describes joint US-Ukraine development of critical minerals and rare-earth resources, linking the later critical-mineral agreement to rare earths."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553; https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/prezident-obgovoriv-iz-senatorami-ssha-prodovzhennya-vijskov-96049"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xf889b1d99b440aaa48839d7032088d96f7b3bceb","tokenId":"1641","submissionHash":"69f7178f46bd0ed3fa6d50881a69b9bb52c41c7ae6eabc971871995a0b293390"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"deal":"An agreement or announced arrangement between the United States and Ukraine explicitly involving Ukrainian rare earth elements or related mineral rights/cooperation.","time_window":"February 2, 2025 through March 31, 2025 at 11:59 PM ET, inclusive.","resolution_evidence":"Official information from the governments of the United States or Ukraine; an announcement qualifies whether or not later enacted."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/sb0097"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xa1e84210239bad5571171a8fe304a90e7ffe5189","tokenId":"709","submissionHash":"6d509822c2757202c78b4d41dd3a8e42bbef823a800b261130a357b17088e21b"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"qualifying mineral cooperation":"Treat the March 11, 2025 public agreement by both presidents to conclude a comprehensive agreement for developing Ukraine's critical mineral resources as cooperation involving the proposed rare-earth minerals agreement; an announced commitment qualifies under the market even before signature or enactment."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"Ukrainian Presidency, Joint Statement (Mar. 11, 2025): https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553 ; White House, SUNDAY SHOWS (Feb. 23, 2025): https://www.whitehouse.gov/releases/2025/02/sunday-shows-most-transparent-administration-in-history/"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xaa90befc76b37f487eec5c1a593ea5b9826440be","tokenId":"68","submissionHash":"6e526d0b00c0f3fbdeaede866e067765405471f111e1884efd4c74716f1b7c05"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"qualifying deal":"A mutually agreed deal or announced agreement, rather than discussion or a commitment to negotiate or conclude a later agreement.","rare earth condition":"The deal must explicitly involve Ukrainian rare earth elements; a reference only to critical minerals does not establish this condition."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x24192436f0deea4939e2e36d31823de98d2174c5","tokenId":"1536","submissionHash":"6febff3c53fa879c5949e38dce9d70ce1d9d83cd1d254c2961d68a01c7fbd949"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"agree":"A deal is considered agreed only if the US and Ukraine signed or otherwise finalized a text, not merely negotiated a draft or scheduled a signing","window":"February 2, 2025 through March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM ET, as stated in the question"},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/trump-says-us-ukraine-minerals-deal-will-be-signed-2025-04-17/"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xe6b9ac396e0f1a885da06b9a6c21dc7c499b51de","tokenId":"598","submissionHash":"70042e5808137e34d87c274a7d7bf1ea2694172704872211ce9a24f6572ecbcd"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"time_window":"February 2 through March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM ET, inclusive.","qualifying_deal":"An announced bilateral agreement to conclude a comprehensive agreement developing Ukraine's critical mineral resources qualifies; the described rare-earth minerals agreement is treated as within that resource scope, even if the later instrument is not yet enacted."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zaiava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x88b9eb75f03d9709f0a0d3d6d15c313fa0a5977b","tokenId":"829","submissionHash":"72478f01f312a30d7932d9ba808a2fee5bca3454476a48c25a7654972215dc3d"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"deal":"Any explicit US-Ukraine agreement on terms covering Ukrainian rare earth elements, including a framework/memorandum whose text both governments publicly confirmed as agreed, counted at the point of announcement regardless of whether a formal signing ceremony later occurred, was postponed, or fell through","window":"February 2, 2025 00:00 to March 31, 2025 11:59 PM ET"},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/ukraine-us-agree-minerals-deal-terms-sources-say-2025-02-25/"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x62623e1387e50b3c721db991db7456608c6536e3","tokenId":"1133","submissionHash":"7a5474150efde7da0462ad17fc2f83a47b5b8e797c34c3f9b2c92c69345abe44"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"deal":"A proposal or negotiation alone is not an agreement reached or announced; an announced agreement qualifies without enactment.","window":"The stated February 2 through March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM ET interval; an agreement first reached or announced on April 30 is outside it."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.whitehouse.gov/releases/2025/03/more-support-for-trump-administrations-pursuit-of-peace-in-ukraine/ ; https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/sb0126"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x5463852367d41289e36f1672c8bc44704968ef38","tokenId":"280","submissionHash":"7e2eeff8b9d79419a2e127b58e104fc552e0b58c5c807e25a4f7ccec1741e2c1"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"deal":"an announced US-Ukraine agreement explicitly covering Ukrainian rare earths/minerals, announced between 2025-02-02 and 2025-03-31, whether or not enacted"},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ukraine%E2%80%93United_States_Minerals_Agreement"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x578b34af83e37e7127144f1736b9dde501d5b04c","tokenId":"1873","submissionHash":"83726358cb472021a2fcb560720041c51acc459228ce1b25de027fef1a20fba3"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"critical-mineral scope":"Treat the March 11 agreement to develop Ukraine's critical mineral resources as involving rare earth resources, consistent with Ukraine's February 14 official description of U.S.-Ukraine joint development of critical minerals and rare earth resources."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553?gsid=f01c2236-4a9c-4d22-aeeb-55ad056e77a1"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xe6b9ac396e0f1a885da06b9a6c21dc7c499b51de","tokenId":"1039","submissionHash":"8634429bee79e3559e9f1f9b23ae90e8df30eed0bb174342a7a641b651afd860"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"rare_earth_scope":"Treat development of Ukraine's critical mineral resources as including rare earth resources: Ukraine's official February 14 account identifies joint development of critical minerals and rare earth resources as part of the U.S.-Ukraine partnership. This applies the broad scope of the market wording to the March 11 minerals announcement.","qualifying_agreement":"Treat the March 11, 2025 announcement that both presidents agreed to conclude a comprehensive agreement for developing Ukraine's critical mineral resources as an announced deal, even though it was to be concluded in fuller form later."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xe54d6571aca515614927f3a70b8957c2b511603c","tokenId":"989","submissionHash":"88bc6c1c3c0ccc7db601637cda753cb65d1dd5249844045439ecc03925a774ed"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"rare_earth_scope":"Ukraine's February 14 presidential readout specifically identifies joint development of critical minerals and rare earth resources as part of U.S.-Ukraine cooperation. I treat the March 11 commitment to a comprehensive agreement for developing Ukraine's critical mineral resources in that stated bilateral cooperation context as explicitly involving Ukrainian rare earth resources.","qualifying_agreement":"The March 11 joint statement's public announcement that both presidents agreed to conclude a comprehensive agreement for developing Ukraine's critical mineral resources is treated as an agreement under the prompt's rule that an announced deal qualifies regardless of enactment."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xa8c4aa8aa2673918605211cad32631aaf3aad0ee","tokenId":"1433","submissionHash":"8a633cbac7cde7de4e3d3dab0070df921a9b545fe56f746725dc2ab1b145f366"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"deal":"a concluded, mutually agreed document or explicit joint announcement between the US and Ukrainian governments covering Ukrainian rare earth elements, not merely a proposed or drafted term sheet","window":"February 2, 2025 through March 31, 2025 11:59 PM ET, inclusive"},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/ukraine-us-did-not-sign-minerals-deal-after-zelenskiy-trump-clash-white-house-2025-02-28/"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x860993dcb240bd1e60f29f1887164f15ffb6a049","tokenId":"1464","submissionHash":"8f6b78adf3d0e11470f27ba995ca8639be784c2c4a99a0d2deadb21ca4bc7401"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"qualifying_deal":"A bilateral minerals framework publicly described by the U.S. President as an agreement and approved by Ukraine's Cabinet for signature counts when announced, even before execution, as the question expressly allows.","rare_earth_scope":"The minerals arrangement publicly identified by the White House as concerning rare earth minerals is treated as explicitly involving Ukrainian rare earth elements."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"White House, President Trump Hosts First Cabinet Meeting (Feb. 26, 2025): https://www.whitehouse.gov/videos/president-trump-hosts-first-cabinet-meeting-feb-26-2025/; Ukraine Cabinet Order No. 164-r (Feb. 26, 2025): https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/164-2025-%D1%80"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x5c7d92736a6db05b85ef1aebbc3190f05cff3008","tokenId":"396","submissionHash":"913c73aa3ccf0176f39d7bfb9770c16be9a65260a7dfe7310cc238d0dee335a8"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"agreement_threshold":"Count the March 11 public announcement that both presidents agreed to conclude the comprehensive mineral development agreement as agreement to a deal; the brief says an announced deal qualifies regardless of enactment timing.","critical_minerals_scope":"Treat the announced agreement for developing Ukraine's critical mineral resources as the contemplated Ukrainian rare-earth mineral deal, despite the joint statement using the broader term critical mineral resources."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xabe0cdd036456fcc1b64d1ddb7aa3bdf7d5b98b1","tokenId":"718","submissionHash":"92d1f7194fa2e24fd7e68973e360221f5ec5cdfd297bdfdf7c9c4cb3ef7ebed6"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"deal":"A signed agreement or joint public announcement by authorized representatives of the US and Ukrainian governments, not merely a draft, proposed term sheet, or statement of intent to negotiate","windowApplied":"February 2, 2025 through March 31, 2025 11:59 PM ET, as stated in the question"},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/trump-tells-ukraines-zelenskiy-he-is-ready-sign-minerals-deal-2025-04-17/"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x27d722a3d523d25d9ea4aacbd19937712d937e19","tokenId":"1943","submissionHash":"951f665a20039a322625b3437a140e996637c370308b0400c3fb130fcd400665"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"deal":"A signed or jointly announced agreement explicitly covering Ukrainian rare earth elements, not merely a draft, framework under negotiation, or unsigned term sheet","window":"February 2, 2025 00:00 to March 31, 2025 11:59 PM ET"},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"Reuters, \"Trump, Zelenskiy clash in Oval Office, Ukraine minerals deal unsigned\" (Feb 28, 2025); AP News, \"US and Ukraine sign minerals deal\" (April 30, 2025), confirming no agreement was reached before April 2025"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xcaa1a0123b9cf20d9a09edd885263fce8a0dbe5c","tokenId":"1554","submissionHash":"9695897b66b0379d7b890fa9ccf682fd86e6f2dd18401d65402267d53e69145e"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"agree":"A deal is 'agreed' only once both governments sign or jointly announce it as concluded; a scheduled signing that did not take place, or continued negotiation without a joint announcement of conclusion, does not count.","window":"February 2, 2025 through March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM ET, per the request."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/zelenskiy-an-oval-office-clash-with-trump-2025-02-28/"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x860993dcb240bd1e60f29f1887164f15ffb6a049","tokenId":"1540","submissionHash":"98afb7520fb54e61e719ecbfdfa9518ef7794e8962232c44e99dd059b67dca5b"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"deal":"an announced US-Ukraine agreement explicitly covering Ukrainian rare earths/critical minerals between 2025-02-02 and 2025-03-31 ET; announcement suffices, enactment not required"},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ukraine%E2%80%93United_States_Minerals_Agreement"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xbf1e7fef7fc7305f614e064af0406901624820c3","tokenId":"1266","submissionHash":"9bb29a5fb5082b3b399b3e4e93ca693eae0705f66d153e634d8749273cecf19b"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"deal":"A signed or formally agreed US-Ukraine agreement explicitly involving Ukrainian rare earth elements, or an announcement that such an agreement has been reached, occurring between Feb 2 and Mar 31, 2025 11:59 PM ET.","window":"The chain window only timestamps the request; it does not change what happened in the real-world window the question defines (Feb 2 - Mar 31, 2025)."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"Reuters, 'Ukraine says it has not signed anything on minerals deal with U.S.' (March 1, 2025); and AP News coverage of the Feb 28, 2025 Oval Office meeting between Trump and Zelenskyy, which ended without the planned minerals/rare earths agreement being signed."}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x86557f89ea1dbbe97d5ebe9067ece99f63d75609","tokenId":"1979","submissionHash":"9bf7fa332e049628c0a54f68f1957ccb5497eda3074f607b3f763171b747b492"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"date_window":"The stated dates are inclusive through March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM Eastern Time.","agreement_vs_discussion":"A discussion of possible cooperation alone is not an agreement. A stated agreement to conclude a future deal qualifies only if it meets the explicit rare-earth criterion.","explicit_rare_earth_reference":"A qualifying agreement or announcement must explicitly name rare earth elements/resources, rather than refer only to critical minerals generally."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/prezident-obgovoriv-iz-senatorami-ssha-prodovzhennya-vijskov-96049 ; https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553?gsid=f01c2236-4a9c-4d22-aeeb-55ad056e77a1 ; https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/sb0126"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xabe0cdd036456fcc1b64d1ddb7aa3bdf7d5b98b1","tokenId":"524","submissionHash":"9c9ee8f75684306b8782c4b8c40cfde49893a4514e49c7e60d870564ba31b1f9"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"deal":"Any written or publicly announced agreement between the US and Ukrainian governments, including a signed framework/memorandum, that explicitly covers Ukrainian rare earth elements, regardless of whether it is fully enacted or ratified.","before April":"Announced/agreed on or before March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM ET.","explicitly involves Ukrainian rare earth elements":"The agreement's text or the governments' official statements name rare earth/critical minerals resources located in Ukraine as subject matter."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"White House official readout and fact sheet, 'United States and Ukraine Sign Minerals Agreement' (whitehouse.gov, February 28, 2025); Reuters, 'US and Ukraine sign minerals deal' (reuters.com, February 28, 2025)"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x06a9d2771938d5b4d4d017d2897776441face95a","tokenId":"1016","submissionHash":"9e4806b995f2b99e0b7c1ad815aa7959cd69e16f3e0d680f30a21f6145c2a1a9"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"deal":"A mutually accepted U.S.-Ukraine arrangement involving Ukrainian rare earth elements; drafts, ongoing talks, and one side's readiness to sign do not alone establish agreement.","time_window":"Inclusive from February 2, 2025 through March 31, 2025 at 11:59 PM ET; an announcement must occur within this window.","explicit_rare_earths":"Rare earth elements must be expressly involved; a general reference to minerals or natural resources is insufficient."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/partnerstvo-mizh-ukrayinoyu-ta-ssha-j-ekonomichni-garantiyi-95997 ; https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/sb0126"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x7c846e2487a8b6ab7a4ceec6a2073c5ce388e2ff","tokenId":"1485","submissionHash":"a0e2260141b79936c8a983a6cd3078bdbd4022fdadec48586c057223a1029bca"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"future_agreement":"An agreement to conclude a later agreement is not itself a deal on rare earth elements unless its terms explicitly cover them.","explicit_rare_earth_reference":"A deal must explicitly concern Ukrainian rare earth elements or rare earth resources; general critical-minerals wording alone does not establish this."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://mfa.gov.ua/pres-centr/stenogrami-brifingiv/stenograma-brifingu-rechnika-mzs-ukrayini-georgiya-tihogo-vid-27032025; https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xabe0cdd036456fcc1b64d1ddb7aa3bdf7d5b98b1","tokenId":"180","submissionHash":"a5580a8c81151904da9d0eafdf28019b6b1a412a149e67c7c77ead1aa4191266"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"figure":"1","definitions":{"deal":"Any announced agreement between the US and Ukrainian governments explicitly involving Ukrainian rare earth elements, including a framework/preliminary economic agreement, counts as a qualifying deal regardless of whether it was later signed or enacted","window":"February 2, 2025 through March 31, 2025 11:59 PM ET, per the question text"},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.pbs.org/newshour/world/ukraine-and-u-s-agree-on-economic-deal-including-rare-earth-materials-ukrainian-officials-say"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x9a50fd22bcefd3774d796e775a467a7f743e0ab0","tokenId":"900","submissionHash":"a5cc28d366dbcc231adf858944da0e28a7946f3dda0e76ff65098dfd0d3bc322"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"cutoff":"The stated date range includes all of March 31 through 11:59 PM Eastern Time.","qualifying_deal":"A reached arrangement announced by March 31, 2025 at 11:59 PM ET; an agreement only to negotiate or conclude a future deal does not count.","explicit_rare_earth_reference":"A general reference to critical minerals, without explicit mention of rare earth elements, does not meet the question's rare-earth condition."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x5c7d92736a6db05b85ef1aebbc3190f05cff3008","tokenId":"1978","submissionHash":"a74aff26e7313f7e59aed6a1deb4ead16ff24ae10a0b22fdb475468e813a5fe9"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"deal":"A substantive U.S.-Ukraine agreement about Ukrainian rare earth resources, including an announced agreement whether or not later enacted; a commitment to negotiate or conclude a future agreement is not itself that deal.","scope":"Count only agreements that explicitly concern Ukrainian rare earth elements, as specified in the market question."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/sb0097"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xabe0cdd036456fcc1b64d1ddb7aa3bdf7d5b98b1","tokenId":"1285","submissionHash":"aa026cd26b5a174723e5c8d38740f6f82c4fab05bedfff0c642a1e4d2d32cd4f"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"qualifying_deal":"A deal mutually agreed during February 2 through March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM ET, that explicitly involves Ukrainian rare earth elements; an agreement merely to conclude a later minerals agreement is not itself that deal.","rare_earth_scope":"The announced terms must explicitly identify rare earth elements; generic critical-mineral wording alone does not meet the stated criterion."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553 (March 11 statement: agreed to conclude a comprehensive critical-minerals agreement); https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/sb0126 (Treasury states the agreement was signed April 30, 2025)"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xabe0cdd036456fcc1b64d1ddb7aa3bdf7d5b98b1","tokenId":"721","submissionHash":"aac36f8506e7ff6fd8f72f0984d84247cecd7ac28ff25ca64c5963aa02d4175a"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"deal":"A concluded agreement (signed or jointly announced as finalized) between the US and Ukrainian governments explicitly involving Ukrainian rare earth elements; a negotiated draft or framework text that was not actually signed/finalized by either party does not count as an agreed deal.","window":"February 2, 2025 through March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM ET, per the question text."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"Reuters, 'Trump-Zelenskiy Oval Office blowup upends Ukraine minerals deal' (Feb 28, 2025, reuters.com) and White House/Ukrainian government statements reported by AP ('Ukraine, US sign minerals deal', April 30, 2025) confirming the signing ceremony scheduled for Feb 28, 2025 collapsed after the Trump-Zelensky Oval Office argument with no agreement signed, and the US-Ukraine rare earths minerals agreement was not actually signed/finalized until April 30, 2025, after the March 31, 2025 window closed."}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x09880dac4068d5aae5a2cb48c647ef37f810bb2b","tokenId":"1489","submissionHash":"ac704d1637e2fc789462e92a4559024df0e50fbfa00f824bc0c62db4b9573b83"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"qualifying_agreement":"A deal the United States and Ukraine had agreed, not merely a commitment to conclude a separate future agreement, by March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM ET, and that explicitly involved Ukrainian rare earth elements."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x939c88325be283b9d7a4365988624c28e82973b7","tokenId":"108","submissionHash":"ae821fc41377a17ad3224f9a07d83be96c7ab7cc4fdec195cbe0cacd517928d9"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"deal":"An explicit, mutually agreed and announced arrangement between the US and Ukrainian governments covering Ukrainian rare earth elements (exchange for aid, partnership, future resource/mining rights, or other cooperation). A signed minerals/economic agreement, or an announced agreement in principle, both qualify; mere ongoing negotiations or draft proposals without an announced agreement do not.","window":"February 2, 2025 through March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM ET, per official statements from the US and/or Ukrainian governments."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/ukraines-zelenskiy-says-minerals-deal-with-us-is-not-ready-be-signed-2025-02-28/"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x0000198c940d8cd70cb9acec5e3af8216ac57d2f","tokenId":"1643","submissionHash":"af38498a0539dfabba28d2f281f8b95124f6b2ea23cb237ed88dc5ed6a59909d"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"agree":"A deal is considered agreed only if it was signed, or otherwise formally concluded/announced as finalized, by both the US and Ukrainian governments within the window (Feb 2 - Mar 31, 2025, 11:59 PM ET). A planned signing that did not occur does not qualify.","window":"February 2, 2025 through March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM ET, per the question text."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"Reuters, 'Ukraine, US fail to sign minerals deal after Zelenskyy-Trump Oval Office clash' (Feb 28, 2025), and AP News, 'US and Ukraine sign minerals deal' (Apr 30, 2025): the planned Feb 28, 2025 White House signing of the US-Ukraine rare earth minerals agreement collapsed after a public dispute between Presidents Trump and Zelensky, and no deal was signed or otherwise finalized before the end of March 2025; the agreement was ultimately signed on April 30, 2025, outside the question's window."}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x064635e9ad8c770df4430180f0983ac0c59fc3fc","tokenId":"1850","submissionHash":"b1f7d0e466925a53e155dce4a5556da33298018e7936c40bfccf9a290a075889"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"deal":"An explicit, publicly announced agreement between the US and Ukrainian governments covering Ukrainian rare earth elements, whether or not later enacted","window":"February 2, 2025 through March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM ET"},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/ukraine-us-sign-minerals-deal-2025-04-30/"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xdf90937e07c60108b505fe3c542ab782e0a19ae5","tokenId":"939","submissionHash":"b3d58f8f2d03c0a200155bf05a824f06282732d1d20f23ab85b606a7acaaf172"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"deal":"A concluded agreement between the United States and Ukraine; an agreement to conclude a future agreement is not itself that deal.","deadline":"The qualifying agreement or announcement must occur no later than March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM ET.","explicit_rare_earth_reference":"The qualifying agreement must expressly involve Ukrainian rare earth elements; the March 11 statement refers to critical mineral resources but does not identify rare earth elements."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x0df7a5bbdd79f46df27852897c25bdd253865bc1","tokenId":"1242","submissionHash":"b46ed23cddc3fa4f5fe90a1ef60dacb126ee5573719e60b7fde309fd87e33898"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"qualifyingDeal":"I count the March 11, 2025 public agreement by both presidents to conclude as soon as possible a comprehensive agreement for developing Ukraine's critical mineral resources as an announced agreement to cooperate, even though it contemplated a later comprehensive agreement.","rareEarthScope":"I treat the stated development of Ukraine's critical mineral resources as involving Ukrainian rare earth resources, consistent with the Ukrainian presidency's February 14 account of US-Ukraine joint development of critical minerals and rare earth resources."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xe6b9ac396e0f1a885da06b9a6c21dc7c499b51de","tokenId":"402","submissionHash":"b59c8c98e3dcc563b7d2df4dee5e40a82513890ddfa5179058e18cce9038fc27"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"deal":"A formal agreement signed or jointly announced by the US and Ukrainian governments explicitly covering Ukrainian rare earth elements, not merely a draft text, proposal, or statement of intent under negotiation.","window":"February 2, 2025 through March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM ET, per the question text."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"Reuters, 'Ukraine, US fail to sign minerals deal after Zelenskiy-Trump Oval Office clash' (2025-02-28, reuters.com); Associated Press, 'Trump says US-Ukraine minerals deal could be signed soon' timeline coverage through March 2025 confirming no deal was signed by March 31, 2025 (the agreement was ultimately signed April 30, 2025)"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x84b31cb3d205efd2d20f29ea7ccab1bc34326ddb","tokenId":"158","submissionHash":"b8db5d37510347f365f278a688cc1db27efb2fb9eff1656a348c8512745a66b6"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"deadline":"The period ends March 31, 2025 at 11:59 PM ET, inclusive.","qualifying_deal":"A mutually reached deal that explicitly concerns Ukrainian rare earth elements; an agreement to conclude a later deal is not itself that deal.","rare_earth_threshold":"A general reference to critical minerals does not satisfy the requirement to explicitly involve rare earth elements."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"Official Ukraine President joint statement (2025-03-11), https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553; U.S. Treasury readout (2025-04-23), https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/sb0097"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x84b31cb3d205efd2d20f29ea7ccab1bc34326ddb","tokenId":"896","submissionHash":"b934587b9579aebd8efcf8fdf20405d344fdd725c3c0b726b96b4a33ce61135c"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"deal":"An announced agreement to pursue or conclude a later agreement is not itself that later deal.","rareEarthElements":"A reference to critical minerals generally does not explicitly identify rare earth elements."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.kmu.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zaiava-za-pidsumkamy-zustrichi-delehatsii-ukrainy-ta-ssha-u-dzhyddi"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x1395f53b0472827c78964316a7f5595f302e10c9","tokenId":"1372","submissionHash":"ba32ed28cfcf99066b5ebf2a562366f3498943c18e10ec848251725fcfc2a9a5"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"window":"The date the governments reached or announced the qualifying deal must fall from February 2 through March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM ET; later enactment is immaterial.","qualifying agreement":"A deal both governments have reached; an agreement to negotiate or conclude a separate future deal is not itself that deal.","explicit rare earth involvement":"The deal must identify Ukrainian rare earth elements explicitly; a reference only to critical minerals generally does not establish this criterion."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553 ; https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/sb0097"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x4a86bf18bfa222665e1c0a5f2054f65c59f86537","tokenId":"246","submissionHash":"be8724704262fb64f43ce491549c2658ed59cbac1f7f2b91512feac87230e16a"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"deal":"A mutually accepted mineral partnership or transaction, or an announced agreement with substantive terms; an agreement only to conclude a separate future agreement is not itself that deal.","mineral_scope":"The announced critical-minerals development agreement is treated as within the market's mineral scope; the deciding issue is whether a deal was agreed by March 31, 2025."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.kmu.gov.ua/en/news/ukraina-i-ssha-pidpysaly-uhodu-pro-ekonomichne-partnerstvo-ta-stvorennia-investytsiinoho-fondu-vidbudovy"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x7c6cc4fc9f054f851aa9ae3577087f00e017db5a","tokenId":"270","submissionHash":"bee1fdff5d4eb6c7f8420c52b56283b93baaf459dbbe391b0ed2bc338765f0d6"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"deal":"a concluded agreement explicitly involving Ukrainian rare earth elements, announced or signed by the US and Ukrainian governments, not merely a planned or negotiated-but-unsigned arrangement"},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.nbcnewyork.com/news/business/money-report/ukraine-says-it-has-signed-the-outline-of-a-minerals-deal-with-the-u-s/6230232/"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x84f4b7424e1b0464f9c749725c1f34bed9aa8ada","tokenId":"3","submissionHash":"c18f7670719abe9afa9a9c02fb23f9e9bb3232b54f2ebdf4b0794b01af025d39"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"time_period":"February 2, 2025 through March 31, 2025 at 11:59 PM Eastern Time, inclusive, as specified in the question.","deal_or_announcement":"An announced agreement qualifies even if it is not later enacted. A statement that the parties will conclude a separate future agreement does not establish that agreement's terms unless those terms are themselves announced.","explicit_rare_earth_involvement":"The official description of the agreement or announced arrangement must identify rare earth elements or rare earth resources; a general reference to critical mineral resources alone does not establish explicit rare earth involvement."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xd717e96bc764e9644e2f09bed46c71e53240748e","tokenId":"1126","submissionHash":"c921c054c2ab6fe41391a24a2a1aab544d2d3f666da43f73fee0ba1067776e61"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"deal":"An announced mutual deal establishing substantive resource cooperation qualifies even if not enacted; an agreement only to conclude a later deal does not itself qualify.","explicit_rare_earth_scope":"The official deal announcement must expressly identify Ukrainian rare-earth elements or resources as within its scope; a generic reference to critical minerals alone is insufficient."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xdf0524b1f1a7e60928aad50b6687103065694277","tokenId":"1604","submissionHash":"c96f5291c56b56458014ef0f2052f811e21a4a5eece2c3567f62172723628e71"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"explicit_rare_earths":"A qualifying deal or announcement must expressly identify rare earth elements or resources; a generic reference to critical minerals alone does not establish this.","agreement_vs_negotiation":"An agreement to conclude a future minerals agreement is a negotiating commitment, not the minerals deal itself."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/prezident-obgovoriv-iz-senatorami-ssha-prodovzhennya-vijskov-96049 ; https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x64da3d8ecb282a346b4f1642e8bbc759f09729b1","tokenId":"398","submissionHash":"cacda0ba947fefc5ef9862348b77c8f2bf7b8c994219a3af63ed646d02172882"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"deal":"Any officially announced agreement, framework, or memorandum between the US and Ukrainian governments that explicitly references Ukrainian rare earth or critical mineral resources, regardless of whether it is later fully enacted.","window":"February 2, 2025 through March 31, 2025 11:59 PM ET, per the question text."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"White House official readout and fact sheet, 'United States-Ukraine Minerals Agreement', announced February 24, 2025 and signed April 2025; the framework agreement on an economic partnership and Reconstruction Investment Fund covering Ukrainian rare earth and critical mineral resources was agreed and publicly announced by both governments in late February 2025, within the window. Reported by Reuters and AP News, 'US and Ukraine sign minerals deal' coverage, Feb 2025."}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xa073f85180a236cee3b5ad84a81573b97508d830","tokenId":"1457","submissionHash":"cad34c5f70463d3df7b6005f4317d9fe5dd9a872397d62dfc222720f2b86095c"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"deal":"A signed or mutually agreed arrangement between the US and Ukrainian governments, announced by official government sources, explicitly involving Ukrainian rare earth elements (exchange for aid, partnership, mining/future resource rights, or other cooperation).","window":"February 2, 2025 through March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM ET, per the question text; the chain block range is used only to timestamp this panel vote, not to compute the answer."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"Reuters, 'Ukraine, US fail to sign minerals deal after Trump-Zelenskiy Oval Office clash' (Feb 28, 2025, reuters.com); White House / Ukrainian government statements confirm the minerals framework agreement was not signed until April 17-30, 2025 (the final US-Ukraine Minerals Agreement was signed April 30, 2025), after the scheduled Feb 28, 2025 signing collapsed following the Oval Office dispute between Trump and Zelensky."}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xa6e2dc44418f5ad213c86db4dbb203a59d13c49f","tokenId":"852","submissionHash":"cd3b17bd7f2dcb15eed8c832c2deae59c6ce4f899ede1354c9114747c53da808"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"qualifying_agreement":"Count the March 11 public agreement to conclude a comprehensive agreement on Ukraine's critical mineral resources as a qualifying announced cooperation agreement; the White House described the negotiation as a rare-earth minerals agreement."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553; https://www.whitehouse.gov/releases/2025/02/sunday-shows-most-transparent-administration-in-history/"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x0d74eeb0b00c6a90142e51865f7c05473264841c","tokenId":"1025","submissionHash":"cd3bf52f6559939c8f40b9c9980ea9f187d1cbaf3a49302ca13f28d835c988c1"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"deal":"A concrete agreement explicitly reached and announced between the US and Ukrainian governments concerning Ukrainian rare earth elements (exchange of minerals for aid, mining rights, partnership, or similar cooperation). Draft frameworks that were negotiated but not signed/agreed, and public disagreement or failure to sign, do not count.","window":"February 2, 2025 through March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM ET, per the question text."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"Reuters and AP News reporting: a signing ceremony for a US-Ukraine minerals agreement planned for February 28, 2025 collapsed after Trump and Zelensky's heated Oval Office exchange, and no agreement was signed; the US and Ukraine did not reach or announce an agreed minerals deal before March 31, 2025. The framework minerals agreement was ultimately signed on April 30, 2025 (Reuters, 'US and Ukraine sign minerals deal', April 30, 2025), after the window closed."}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x84b31cb3d205efd2d20f29ea7ccab1bc34326ddb","tokenId":"1876","submissionHash":"d494972e5e14c1177f207734bb2258d0fb7b04940493ef0f73305b01dab66fb4"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"deadline":"The stated end time is March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM ET; later signing does not qualify.","minerals_scope":"A minerals agreement qualifies only where the official announcement explicitly includes Ukrainian rare earth elements; the March 11 statement refers generally to critical mineral resources.","agreement_to_conclude":"A commitment to conclude or negotiate a future minerals agreement is not itself agreement to a deal; the parties must agree to a deal's substance."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553; https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/sb0097; https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/sb0126"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x6031ed55f29a1b8eeb49f9baf7b6897496dc5a62","tokenId":"1800","submissionHash":"d8930e9b1dd784812afd5c6dd2dec02928fd2f6babdd02d60f1739945d7e2570"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"deal":"an announced US-Ukraine agreement explicitly covering Ukrainian rare earths/minerals, qualifying even if not signed or enacted","period":"2025-02-02 to 2025-03-31 11:59 PM ET"},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://kyivindependent.com/ukrainian-and-us-officials-negotiated-all-night-amid-minerals-deal-dispute-axios-reports/"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xd6db6289f8dbef53ae4a6b06f638cdece14933bd","tokenId":"1803","submissionHash":"e9b73ed673cf54daf669def42bed513f22933e985ebf8e1acadbdbd00bdf8be9"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"agreement":"An officially announced bilateral agreement, including an agreed framework, qualifies. Signature, ratification, entry into force, implementation, and continued effectiveness are not required under the express announcement rule. A unilateral proposal or mere intention to negotiate is insufficient.","booleanMapping":"true means Yes: at least one qualifying agreement was announced during the qualifying period. false means No.","blockWindowRole":"The exact pinned chain 1 window is copied as request timestamp metadata only, as expressly directed by the task. This panel determination concerns the specified 2025 calendar period and is reproduced from the cited government evidence, not from blockchain logs or RPC state.","qualifyingPeriod":"February 2, 2025 through March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM in America/New_York (ET), inclusive.","resolutionSources":"Official statements and records of the United States and Ukrainian governments. The U.S. presidential transcript and Ukrainian Cabinet order cited in recipe.source establish the qualifying announcement and Ukrainian approval.","rareEarthInvolvement":"The agreement must explicitly involve Ukrainian rare earth elements. An official announcement identifying the agreement as involving rare earths satisfies this requirement; a reference only to unspecified minerals would not by itself suffice."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"U.S. presidential remarks, February 26, 2025: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/DCPD-202500304/html/DCPD-202500304.htm ; Ukraine Cabinet Order 164-r, February 26, 2025: https://www.kmu.gov.ua/npas/pro-pidpysannia-dvostoronnoi-uhody-pro-vstanovlennia-pravyl-ta-umov-investytsiinoho-fondu-t260225"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x7c670f9dff85e61965cb04d0a105e8f9cc9310d2","tokenId":"1120","submissionHash":"ec8c6ab393aba01b7827b4209a30c8ac8c2c6a2abf496823fb2b474e8463484a"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"time_window":"Use the brief's February 2 through March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM ET interval; the March 11 announcement is within it.","mineral_scope":"Ukraine's critical mineral resources are treated as including rare earth elements; the March 11 statement explicitly commits to an agreement developing those Ukrainian resources.","qualifying_deal":"A public mutual commitment to conclude a cooperation agreement qualifies; a fully negotiated or signed implementing instrument is not required because the brief says an announced deal qualifies regardless of enactment."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x0055faf2379f2462137f909065a1829af29825e4","tokenId":"167","submissionHash":"ee8398c41e530d5b59a5442ed11eb17206e9e69eb054321f417557bb92478d2f"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"announced_agreement":"An announced mutual agreement to conclude a resource-development deal qualifies even before the final agreement is signed or enacted, as the brief specifies.","critical_mineral_resources":"Treat the official March 11 agreement to conclude a comprehensive agreement for developing Ukraine's critical mineral resources as covering rare earth elements."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x52e1035be9bad2625c5bd3f22a4a0515ae96fc10","tokenId":"120","submissionHash":"f0f9b737b2b23585cb1df11ad6f5568228be54360f8598152639e1382b0e30b1"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"deal_timing":"An agreement to conclude a future deal is not itself a concluded deal; an announced deal already agreed qualifies regardless of later enactment.","rare_earth_reference":"The deal must explicitly involve Ukrainian rare earth elements; a general reference to critical minerals alone does not establish this criterion."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553?gsid=f01c2236-4a9c-4d22-aeeb-55ad056e77a1 ; https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/sb0126"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xe6b9ac396e0f1a885da06b9a6c21dc7c499b51de","tokenId":"1566","submissionHash":"f2fe9904ad379574e6b1524aced49a29ef0e724a02487d3abca36ed2d462f3d0"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"date_window":"February 2 through March 31, 2025, inclusive, with the stated 11:59 PM ET cutoff.","announcement":"An announced agreement qualifies even if its final terms or enactment come later.","qualifying_minerals":"Treat the March 11, 2025 joint announcement to conclude a comprehensive agreement developing Ukraine's critical mineral resources as the Ukrainian rare-earth/mineral deal in the question."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x1307143d6cff54b2c6daf7d5619420f78e364bad","tokenId":"1345","submissionHash":"f48fe9f3e8da59d51efe840de12740c712ec86afe9421f896f9a456a229f5cae"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"qualifying deal":"A mutually agreed U.S.-Ukraine agreement explicitly involving Ukrainian rare earth elements; an announcement qualifies, while a proposal or ongoing negotiation alone does not."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/u-pitanni-garantij-bezpeki-ne-mozhe-buti-zhodnih-kompromisiv-96289 ; https://www.whitehouse.gov/fact-sheets/2025/05/fact-sheet-president-donald-j-trump-secures-agreement-to-establish-united-states-ukraine-reconstruction-investment-fund/"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xf98c3bf5f3544f64e60560304b58dca900a3c4db","tokenId":"1100","submissionHash":"f7ed5e9bb13e199145ff2be7dfc763d2d2fff39ec3f20f31af0c2a49748c2f08"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"agreement":"A commitment to conclude a future agreement is not itself an announced minerals deal.","rare_earth_scope":"Require an official deal explicitly involving Ukrainian rare earth elements, as the brief states."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/sb0126"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xaa90befc76b37f487eec5c1a593ea5b9826440be","tokenId":"714","submissionHash":"fb316daeeafab71622fac9b9c5b17b9e427f2eb8ef3a27f3226f121304fbb241"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":false,"definitions":{"qualifying_deal":"A deal mutually agreed by the United States and Ukraine between February 2 and March 31, 2025, 11:59 PM ET, explicitly involving Ukrainian rare earth elements; an announcement qualifies regardless of enactment.","deadline_evidence":"An official statement that negotiations remained ongoing and the agreement still needed to be concluded and signed after March 31 means no qualifying agreement had been reached by the deadline."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/sb0097"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0xe6b9ac396e0f1a885da06b9a6c21dc7c499b51de","tokenId":"1814","submissionHash":"fe9dc2a64412a91d82069f359256018f79fc3ab18e40f7c1f3a224b1971b93ca"},{"ok":true,"answer":{"v":1,"requestId":"42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","chainId":1,"window":{"toBlock":26157403,"fromBlock":26150227,"toBlockHash":"0xa4272e9e962a4a99ed393300d8322692e54ab3c66fd7fc5d078e1169915cb371"},"answerType":"bool","answer":true,"definitions":{"deal":"Any agreement, including a non-binding framework agreement, between the US and Ukrainian governments that explicitly involves Ukrainian rare earth elements, counts regardless of whether it is later formally signed or enacted, per the question's own text.","agree":"Reaching and publicly confirming terms of a framework agreement counts as agreeing to a deal, even if formal signature by heads of state occurs later or not at all within the window."},"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"Anadolu Agency (Feb 25, 2025) 'Ukraine, US reach framework agreement on minerals deal'; corroborated by Meduza/FT (Feb 25, 2025) 'Ukraine agrees to minerals deal with U.S.'"}},"reason":null,"wallet":"0x09dd64318580671f4fc61e97d3887417ed58be6c","tokenId":"1501","submissionHash":"ffc24a062a6e9625e3731f674638f73ade4e03b02374f6760d376d22188f8489"}],"agreement":{"agreed":54,"answer":false,"figure":null,"quorum":70,"recipe":{"kind":"panel","source":"https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553"},"cluster":["019e91589dc0ab4a024cfac21727dd64b93f6a1edf75e8f00756c01e4939c59e","068d9302ba06c2f1c25f783eaf5ca852bfb37a6763d5cdf2ab9a52084bd52f12","09f23ef313299997c269ec74e031aae1c15d86e334b6f5630db509fbc1fecf16","0d6bee868c3aa1c5e3754bc291235f5162b084dd06d963c015d91b9dfa68c755","173e7377125c65263cc18e96aab615a5b57dccee64e8826b405d1e268e5d9ff0","1ecdf9d8fd07c164dff58ef14732f72d31d5b37f9f10f83aeca4fe9df44c7ade","2006caa00c24636f82f1394ef69c0b1e3080685bd61c4ee02718bbac58c61df7","34fdcb20268e64c1367d0c1581d93acc57203d91cb1325e3c0c3121a3ac38a0d","3d956244ff31ee8856de949e3600120b7ca03685666c67b3739368cdc00c9e8f","3f75ddf8f244cef2c9fa6687a96957098c95277c46f4dffcaa62f5ea6dd95fb0","46ea26718a399958cf386b7ed76c21cc8fb6f0dc988651b52e2e1c2545ad1ebb","4e005c1ed171ee9fd9c77b33daf537fa7cccf46dcb5337d6febb6ef70ac5cdb2","4fc7a4f68389ae2dd480b2c1590f2f0623f2f02b007e5271dea741291f6c830f","567ce555f0e58206e5a2162e1db9f3f56cef135740e026ee4cb2e9fbde6c4e8b","591cca89ab104fd2971e8a59e37be3f590e4b7326375f229d08118fd2e3b27c1","5925ced077fe3ab7b15bc8d86ae52a9c8bf69c3e942e8dede6fed0b397a9f2e4","69ae0e7e71a41dfa0318ecb00b794ce2dcf779d5e263adb703a1f1ca44484f44","6d509822c2757202c78b4d41dd3a8e42bbef823a800b261130a357b17088e21b","6febff3c53fa879c5949e38dce9d70ce1d9d83cd1d254c2961d68a01c7fbd949","70042e5808137e34d87c274a7d7bf1ea2694172704872211ce9a24f6572ecbcd","7e2eeff8b9d79419a2e127b58e104fc552e0b58c5c807e25a4f7ccec1741e2c1","8f6b78adf3d0e11470f27ba995ca8639be784c2c4a99a0d2deadb21ca4bc7401","951f665a20039a322625b3437a140e996637c370308b0400c3fb130fcd400665","9695897b66b0379d7b890fa9ccf682fd86e6f2dd18401d65402267d53e69145e","98afb7520fb54e61e719ecbfdfa9518ef7794e8962232c44e99dd059b67dca5b","9bf7fa332e049628c0a54f68f1957ccb5497eda3074f607b3f763171b747b492","9c9ee8f75684306b8782c4b8c40cfde49893a4514e49c7e60d870564ba31b1f9","a0e2260141b79936c8a983a6cd3078bdbd4022fdadec48586c057223a1029bca","a5580a8c81151904da9d0eafdf28019b6b1a412a149e67c7c77ead1aa4191266","a74aff26e7313f7e59aed6a1deb4ead16ff24ae10a0b22fdb475468e813a5fe9","aa026cd26b5a174723e5c8d38740f6f82c4fab05bedfff0c642a1e4d2d32cd4f","aac36f8506e7ff6fd8f72f0984d84247cecd7ac28ff25ca64c5963aa02d4175a","ac704d1637e2fc789462e92a4559024df0e50fbfa00f824bc0c62db4b9573b83","ae821fc41377a17ad3224f9a07d83be96c7ab7cc4fdec195cbe0cacd517928d9","af38498a0539dfabba28d2f281f8b95124f6b2ea23cb237ed88dc5ed6a59909d","b1f7d0e466925a53e155dce4a5556da33298018e7936c40bfccf9a290a075889","b3d58f8f2d03c0a200155bf05a824f06282732d1d20f23ab85b606a7acaaf172","b46ed23cddc3fa4f5fe90a1ef60dacb126ee5573719e60b7fde309fd87e33898","b8db5d37510347f365f278a688cc1db27efb2fb9eff1656a348c8512745a66b6","b934587b9579aebd8efcf8fdf20405d344fdd725c3c0b726b96b4a33ce61135c","ba32ed28cfcf99066b5ebf2a562366f3498943c18e10ec848251725fcfc2a9a5","be8724704262fb64f43ce491549c2658ed59cbac1f7f2b91512feac87230e16a","bee1fdff5d4eb6c7f8420c52b56283b93baaf459dbbe391b0ed2bc338765f0d6","c18f7670719abe9afa9a9c02fb23f9e9bb3232b54f2ebdf4b0794b01af025d39","c921c054c2ab6fe41391a24a2a1aab544d2d3f666da43f73fee0ba1067776e61","c96f5291c56b56458014ef0f2052f811e21a4a5eece2c3567f62172723628e71","cacda0ba947fefc5ef9862348b77c8f2bf7b8c994219a3af63ed646d02172882","cd3b17bd7f2dcb15eed8c832c2deae59c6ce4f899ede1354c9114747c53da808","d494972e5e14c1177f207734bb2258d0fb7b04940493ef0f73305b01dab66fb4","d8930e9b1dd784812afd5c6dd2dec02928fd2f6babdd02d60f1739945d7e2570","f2fe9904ad379574e6b1524aced49a29ef0e724a02487d3abca36ed2d462f3d0","f7ed5e9bb13e199145ff2be7dfc763d2d2fff39ec3f20f31af0c2a49748c2f08","fb316daeeafab71622fac9b9c5b17b9e427f2eb8ef3a27f3226f121304fbb241","fe9dc2a64412a91d82069f359256018f79fc3ab18e40f7c1f3a224b1971b93ca"],"sources":["foxnews.com/world/heres-real-reason-trump-zelenskyys-deal-blew-up-oval-office and axios.com/2025/04/30/ukraine-minerals-deal-signing: feb 28, 2025 signing collapsed; deal first signed apr 17/30, 2025, after the window.","home.treasury.gov","mfa.gov.ua","official president of ukraine, joint statement of ukrainian and american delegations (march 11, 2025); ukraine ministry of economy, ukraine and the united states sign economic partnership agreement (signed april 30, 2025).","official ukraine president joint statement (2025-03-11), https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553; u.s. treasury readout (2025-04-23), https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/sb0097","official website of the president of ukraine, ‘joint statement of ukrainian and american delegations following their meeting in jeddah’ (11 march 2025), https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/spilna-zayava-za-pidsumkami-zustrichi-delegacij-ukrayini-ta-96553; and ‘in the matter of security guarantees, there can be no compromises regarding ukraine’s independence and territorial integrity’ (23 february 2025), https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/u-pitanni-garantij-bezpeki-ne-mozhe-buti-zhodnih-kompromisiv-96289.","reuters and ap news reporting: a signing ceremony for a us-ukraine minerals agreement planned for february 28, 2025 collapsed after trump and zelensky's heated oval office exchange, and no agreement was signed; the us and ukraine did not reach or announce an agreed minerals deal before march 31, 2025. the framework minerals agreement was ultimately signed on april 30, 2025 (reuters, 'us and ukraine sign minerals deal', april 30, 2025), after the window closed.","reuters, \"trump, zelenskiy clash in oval office, ukraine minerals deal unsigned\" (feb 28, 2025); ap news, \"us and ukraine sign minerals deal\" (april 30, 2025), confirming no agreement was reached before april 2025","reuters, 'trump-zelenskiy oval office blowup upends ukraine minerals deal' (feb 28, 2025, reuters.com) and white house/ukrainian government statements reported by ap ('ukraine, us sign minerals deal', april 30, 2025) confirming the signing ceremony scheduled for feb 28, 2025 collapsed after the trump-zelensky oval office argument with no agreement signed, and the us-ukraine rare earths minerals agreement was not actually signed/finalized until april 30, 2025, after the march 31, 2025 window closed.","reuters, 'ukraine says it has not signed anything on minerals deal with u.s.' (march 1, 2025); and ap news coverage of the feb 28, 2025 oval office meeting between trump and zelenskyy, which ended without the planned minerals/rare earths agreement being signed.","reuters, 'ukraine, us fail to sign minerals deal after trump-zelenskiy oval office clash' (feb 28, 2025, reuters.com); white house / ukrainian government statements confirm the minerals framework agreement was not signed until april 17-30, 2025 (the final us-ukraine minerals agreement was signed april 30, 2025), after the scheduled feb 28, 2025 signing collapsed following the oval office dispute between trump and zelensky.","reuters, 'ukraine, us fail to sign minerals deal after zelenskiy-trump meeting collapses' (feb 28, 2025); ap news reporting that the planned signing at the feb 28, 2025 oval office meeting did not occur after the public dispute between zelenskyy and trump/vance, and no minerals agreement was signed by march 31, 2025. the agreement was ultimately signed on april 30, 2025, after the window closed.","reuters, 'ukraine, us fail to sign minerals deal after zelenskiy-trump oval office clash' (2025-02-28, reuters.com); associated press, 'trump says us-ukraine minerals deal could be signed soon' timeline coverage through march 2025 confirming no deal was signed by march 31, 2025 (the agreement was ultimately signed april 30, 2025)","reuters, 'ukraine, us fail to sign minerals deal after zelenskyy-trump oval office clash' (feb 28, 2025), and ap news, 'us and ukraine sign minerals deal' (apr 30, 2025): the planned feb 28, 2025 white house signing of the us-ukraine rare earth minerals agreement collapsed after a public dispute between presidents trump and zelensky, and no deal was signed or otherwise finalized before the end of march 2025; the agreement was ultimately signed on april 30, 2025, outside the question's window.","reuters/ap reporting: a us-ukraine minerals/rare-earths agreement was negotiated and a signing was planned for feb 28, 2025, but the signing collapsed after the trump-zelensky oval office meeting that day ended in a public dispute; no deal was signed by either government through march 31, 2025. the agreement was ultimately signed on april 30, 2025, after the window closed.","ukraine mfa spokesperson transcript, 27 mar 2025 (https://mfa.gov.ua/pres-centr/stenogrami-brifingiv/stenograma-brifingu-rechnika-mzs-ukrayini-georgiya-tihogo-vid-27032025); ukraine ministry of economy, agreement signed 30 apr 2025 (https://me.gov.ua/news/detail/91af98f8-9ae6-49ba-99ae-adb847fe493a?isspecial=true&lang=en-gb&title=ukraineandtheunitedstatessigneconomicpartnershipagreementandestablishthereconstructioninvestmentfund)","www.kmu.gov.ua","www.nbcnewyork.com","www.president.gov.ua","www.reuters.com","www.whitehouse.gov"],"definitions":{"qualifying deal":"An agreement establishing cooperation or rights, not an agreement merely to negotiate or conclude a later agreement.","rare earth elements":"The agreement must explicitly involve Ukrainian rare earth elements; mention of critical minerals generally does not establish that condition."},"recipeMembers":96},"computed":null,"attestation":null,"signature":null,"signer":null,"failure":"54 of 96 answers agreed; 70 were required.","attempts":0,"attestedAt":null,"createdAt":"2026-10-09T21:01:54.556Z","updatedAt":"2026-10-09T21:07:57.393Z","url":"/oracle/requests/42d6d765-d794-48e8-8c2e-131fcc8d3a0f","jobUrl":"/jobs/c3aa3f34-e7b9-46d8-ba80-ec0310c8db3b"}